Dec 14, 2012
D3football.com Offensive Player of the Year:
Nate Wara, Sr., QB, UW-Oshkosh
D3football.com Defensive Player of the
Year: Javicz Jones, Sr., LB, Mary Hardin-Baylor
D3football.com Coach of the Year: Larry
Kehres, Mount Union
| Pos. | First Team | Second Team |
| QB | Nate Wara, Sr., UW-Oshkosh | LiDarral Bailey, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| RB | Scottie Williams, Sr., Elmhurst | Cole Myhra, Jr., UW-Oshkosh |
| RB | Dominique Carson, Sr., Sul Ross State | Cartel Brooks, So., Heidelberg |
| WR | Eric Rogers, Sr., Cal Lutheran | D'Mario Parker, Sr., Louisiana College |
| WR | Jasper Collins, Sr., Mount Union | Mark Hiben, So., Wheaton (Ill.) |
| TE | Adam Carl, Jr., Augsburg | Billy Chapman, Sr., Middlebury |
| T | Antonio Tate, Sr., Mount Union | Sam Maxie, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| G | Michael Coles, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Brian Cranmer, Sr., Wesley |
| C | Curtis James, Sr., St. Thomas | Mac Knisely, Sr., Mount Union |
| G | Matt Mattox, Sr., Mount Union | Drew Wert, Sr., Linfield |
| T | Ryan Moores, Sr., Middlebury | Charlie Homoky, Sr., Elmhurst |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Brynnan Hyland, Jr., Linfield | Frank Weymiller, Sr., Coe |
| DT | Mike Raplee, Sr., Alfred | Undra Hendrix, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| DT | D.J. Chappell, Sr., Huntingdon | Mychael Tuiasosopo, Jr., Pacific Lutheran |
| DE | Tyre Coleman, So., Hobart | Devin Hardy, Sr., Wesley |
| LB | Javicz Jones, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Devin Worthington, Jr., Hobart |
| LB | Charles Dieuseul, Sr., Mount Union | Dom Forrest, Jr., Linfield |
| LB | Seth Mathis, Jr., Bethel | Sosthene Kapepula, So., Wesley |
| CB | Keith Villafranco, Jr., Mississippi College | Tim Filter, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| S | Nick Driskill, Sr., Mount Union | Zach Autenrieb, Sr., Thomas More |
| S | Jared Morris, Sr., Wesley | Cody Pastorino, Sr., Willamette |
| CB | Bobby Fischer, Sr., St. John's | Isaiah Scott, Sr., Mount Union |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Allen Cain, Sr., Texas Lutheran | Kevin Grady, Jr., Redlands |
| P | Christian Hallingstad, Sr., UW-La Crosse | Jordan Gay, Sr., Centre |
| RET | Chris Denton, Sr., Mount Union | Dwayne Hollis, Sr., North Carolina Wesleyan |
| Pos. | Third Team | Fourth Team |
| QB | Kevin Burke, So., Mount Union | Mickey Inns, Sr., Linfield |
| RB | James Clay, Sr, Mount St. Joseph | Luke Heinsohn, Sr., Washington and Lee |
| RB | Melikke Van Alstyne, Jr., Framingham State | Jonathan Rigaud, Sr., Johns Hopkins |
| WR | Brandon Boyle, Jr., Castleton State | Lee Carothers, Sr., Sul Ross State |
| WR | Jeremy Meier, Sr., Utica | Kyle Linville, Jr., Franklin |
| TE | Calvin Cagney, So., Ohio Wesleyan | Adam Moses, Sr., Waynesburg |
| T | Brandon Peter, Sr., UW-Oshkosh | Armand Jennifer, Jr., Johns Hopkins |
| G | Art Garvey, Sr., Hobart | Nick Schultz, Sr., Franklin |
| C | Travis Sugar, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Ben Strehlow, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| G | John Lavelle, Sr., Delaware Valley | Nathan Yelton, Jr., Coe |
| T | Tom Knowlton, Sr., Concordia-Moorhead | Mike Wutzer, Sr., Cortland State |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Clay Eaton, Sr., Oberlin | Patrick Seesholtz, Jr., Otterbein |
| DT | Matt Fechko, Jr., Mount Union | James Muirhead, Sr., Framingham State |
| DT | Silvio Diaz, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Brandon Dykstra, Jr., Wheaton (Ill.) |
| DE | Ayo Idowu, Sr., St. Thomas | Andrew Thompson, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| LB | Erik Westerberg, Jr., Augustana | Taylor Goodman, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| LB | Andre Carter, Jr., LaGrange | Noah Joseph, Sr., Union |
| LB | Craig Sykes, Sr., Heidelberg | Tremayne Williams, Jr., St. Thomas |
| CB | Zack Corpe, Jr., Franklin | Ryan Wenkman, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| S | John Robinson, Sr., Delaware Valley | Rae Haynes, Sr., Trinity (Conn.) |
| S | Demetreus Johnson, Sr., Coe | Chinni Oji, Sr., St. Thomas |
| CB | Phil Terio, So., Salve Regina | Tony Tatum, Sr., Gallaudet |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Will Jeffcoat, Jr., LaGrange | Jimmie Mattson, Sr., St. John's |
| P | Michael Parks, Jr., Franklin | Jeff Sauer, Sr., Chicago |
| RET | Graham Asum, Sr., Worcester State | Phil Terio, So., Salve Regina |