Poll positions: What to make of regional rankings

At the moment, Millsaps' regional ranking might leave them on the outside looking in for a Pool B bid. But as an unbeaten team, they'd certainly get an at-large bid.
Millsaps athletics photo

So the regional rankings are out, and for the beginner and advanced playoff-field watcher alike, there's information to be gleaned.

Before we dig too deep, let's make sure we understand what we're looking at. The regional rankings are compiled individually in each region by an NCAA-appointed subcommittee of coaches, ADs and conference commissioners. The subcommittee (regional advisory committee) meets weekly by teleconference to discuss the rankings long before Wednesday's first public release. Another set of rankings comes next Wednesday and a third set, while not publicly released, is used to help select the field after Week 11’s games are in the books.

Each eight-member subcommitee has two members at the helm who make up part of the eight-person national committee that selects and seeds the playoff field of 32. That selection committee has a set of primary and secondary criteria that it follows to ensure that assembling of the field is based on more than just opinion.

The D3football.com Top 25 poll (and the coaches poll) is completely unrelated to these rankings and has no influence on playoff selection. If you're new to the process, before you complain, please educate yourself. Here’s the championships handbook the NCAA and schools use, or you can get the basics without all of the extras by reading our FAQ.

The other thing to keep in mind is that this first set of rankings is highly fluid. Even though it's already Week 10 of an 11-week regular season, the final two Saturdays feature a number of big games that could turn the rankings upside down. A sampling:

Week 10:

North Central at Wheaton
Heidelberg at John Carroll
Wittenberg at Wabash
Ithaca at Salisbury
St. Lawrence at Hobart
Concordia-Moorhead at St. Thomas
Pacific at Willamette

Week 11:

John Carroll at Mount Union
Linfield at Pacific
Bethel at St. John's
UW-Platteville at UW-Oshkosh
Millsaps at Rhodes
Cortland State at Ithaca
Alfred at St. John Fisher
Salve Regina at Endicott
Chicago at Wash. U.
St. Norbert at Lake Forest
Widener at Delaware Valley
Hampden-Sydney at Randolph-Macon

And one final thing to keep in mind. Twenty-four of the 32 playoff spots are automatic, meaning they go to champions of conferences with seven or more members who have been in existence for longer than two years. This is referred to as Pool A. So the regional rankings, and the playoff selection committee, really only puts eight teams into the field. These, however, are the eight most hotly contested bids.

Here are Wednesday's rankings, republished with expected automatic qualifiers omitted:


6 Framingham State 7-1 7-1
7 Alfred 6-2 6-2
8 St. John Fisher 6-2 6-2
10 St. Lawrence 6-2 6-2


- Wabash/Witt loser
5 John Carroll/Heidelberg winner
6 Illinois Wesleyan 7-1 7-1
8 Wheaton (Ill.) 7-1 7-1


3 Texas Lutheran 7-0 7-0
4 Wesley 4-2 6-2
5 Millsaps 8-0 8-0
8 Washington U. 6-2 6-2
10 Washington and Jefferson 6-2 6-2


4 UW-Oshkosh 7-1 7-1
5 Concordia-Moorhead 7-1 7-1
6 UW-Platteville 7-1 7-1
7 Pacific Lutheran 7-1 7-1
10 St. John’s 6-2 6-2

From this group, three Pool B teams (those from non-AQ conferences SAA, SCAC, UAA, MASCAC and independents, eligible teams in bold) and five Pool C (runners-up in AQ conferences) will be selected.

In the East, Hobart and St. Lawrence face off, and Ithaca, Alfred, St. John Fisher and Salisbury will beat up on each other until there's one AQ team and none with a realistic Pool C shot left.

In the North, Wittenberg and Wabash, John Carroll's two big games, and Wheaton's game against North Central will change things. Wheaton only stays in the picture if they beat North Central. North Central would likely still win the CCIW AQ on points-differential among h2h tiebreaker with IWU and Wheaton. If North Central wins as expected, and Mount Union finishes unbeaten, the JCU/Heidelberg loser is out.

In the South, Texas Lutheran, Wesley and Millsaps and Wash U. would all be in Pool B -- these regional rankings were good news for Wesley's thought-to-be-shot playoff hopes. W&J and Thomas More won't be in the picture - one will win the AQ, the other won't stack up in Pool C.

In the West, you have to consider Pacific and St. Thomas part of the picture even though they aren't regionally ranked. Oshkosh or Platteville will knock one another out.

So that leaves this:

Texas Lutheran, Framingham State, Wesley, Millsaps and Wash U. in Pool B.

Wabash/Witt loser, John Carroll/Heidelberg winner, Oshkosh/Platteville winner, Pacific Lutheran, Concordia-Moorhead and Illinois Wesleyan in Pool C.

Unexpected problems could arise, if say, John Carroll beat Mount Union, Bethel lost to St. John's (check this, they might be good anyway) or Illinois College lost the MWC tiebreaker.

But if things break as expected -- and when do they ever? -- we could be looking at a couple pretty clean-cut playoff pictures.

Adam Turer

Adam Turer graduated in 2006 from Washington and Lee University, where he was a two-year starter at free safety. He lives in Cincinnati and covers area high school sports in addition to his full-time job as an attorney. Adam has contributed to D3football.com since 2007 and is in his first season writing Around the Nation after spending four seasons writing Around the Mid-Atlantic.

2014-2015 columnist: Ryan Tipps.
2001-2013 columnist: Keith McMillan.

Previous Columns

December 20, 2016
Year in review: The year everything changed
We had a brand-new Division III national champion for the first time since 2007. Mount Union lost a...
November 17, 2016
Playoff picks, surprises, disappointments
Around the Nation has assembled a team of prognosticators for an annual look at who might surprise...
November 13, 2016
Snap Judgments: Hellos and goodbyes
Today is going to be bittersweet for many. We take a look at the teams that announced their arrival...
November 10, 2016
Out of the darkness, light
Sometimes, things don’t go your way. Sometimes, your highest expectations are crushed by...
November 6, 2016
Snap Judgments: Merry Clinchmas
The playoff field is nearly halfway set. Twelve teams are in, which means there are several teams...
November 2, 2016
Heart of the Heartland
Melissa Johnson has spent more than three years battling pancreatitis and complications from...
October 30, 2016
Snap Judgments: Don't forget about us
When one team dominates a conference, it's easy to forget about the second place team. JCU,...
October 27, 2016
September's stumblers now rolling
Some of September's most disappointing teams have been able to reverse their fortunes. Heading into...
October 23, 2016
Snap Judgments: Controlling your own destiny
With three weeks of regular season play remaining, 16 playoff contenders remain undefeated. For fans...
October 20, 2016
Handling the political football
A summer on Capitol Hill, an internship at a national convention, or a spring abroad at an embassy...
October 16, 2016
Snap Judgments: Don't sleep
Week 7 had wire-to-wire excitement. We can't wait to see what Week 8 brings. After over 12 hours of...
October 13, 2016
Remembering a fallen brother
At Wittenberg, or Lake Forest, a helmet sticker hardly suffices to counteract the emotion of losing...
October 9, 2016
Snap judgments: Are we having fun yet?
Saturday was thrilling. Week 6 had several exciting finishes that will be remembered for a long...
October 6, 2016
Finding a home in purple
With the returning offensive player of the year, St. Thomas might not have been a place a running...
October 2, 2016
Snap judgments: What do we know?
Conference play is in full swing. Some results created clear separation, while others caused more...
September 29, 2016
Re-ranking the conferences for 2016
It’s not easy to compare conferences. Some are no-brainers. Guess what? The WIAC, with three...
September 25, 2016
Snap Judgments: Survival Saturday
Saturday showed that Top 25 teams are far from infallible. Seven teams had to eke out single-digit...
September 22, 2016
Ohana means family
Eventually, the final score will be forgotten. Certain plays will fade away. But the experience that...
September 18, 2016
Snap judgments: A humbling Week 3
Saturday featured multiple marquee matchups of ranked teams taking to the road. There were long...
September 15, 2016
The playcaller and the playwright
A theatre professor spent two seasons behind the scenes with the UW-Oshkosh coaching staff and...
September 11, 2016
Snap judgments: Time to dig deep
No team expects to open the season 0-2. Conference play will afford these teams the opportunity to...
September 7, 2016
Fuentes walks off, a decade later
Julio Fuentes was paralyzed in the opening game of his sophomore season for Alfred. Ten years later,...
September 4, 2016
Snap judgments: The excitement is back
Week 1 had it all. Impressive debuts from coaches and players, thrilling comebacks, and Top 25...
September 1, 2016
Football is here: Get fired up!
New Around the Nation columnist Adam Turer introduces himself to the national audience, introduces a...
 • More Division III football news releases

Other Columnists