September 24, 2013

Poll positions: How the voters reacted

Wesley couldn't shake off the UMHB starting defense, and the Wolverines' poll position suffered.
Photo by Andrew Zavoina, 

The strangest reaction of voters after two top-five teams lost on Saturday wasn't the redistribution of St. Thomas's seven first-place votes. It was where the Tommies landed, as compared to then-No. 5 Wesley.

The Wolverines dropped from No. 5 to No. 11 after losing 35-7 on the road to No. 4 Mary Hardin-Baylor, which went from one No. 1 vote to five after the win. St. Thomas only dropped from No. 2 to No. 6 despite losing at home to then-unranked St. John's. The margin of victory, 20-18, and the fact that the Tommies could have won the game if Paul Graupner's 32-yard field goal attempt at the end hadn't been wide left, probably accounts for St. Thomas's modest fall.

Those were the reasons behind me dropping the Tommies to 10th on my ballot and moving St. John's in at No. 22, going against one of my cardinal rules of early-season voting: Respect the W's. Normally, early in the year when there aren't other results to contradict them, it's usually safe to assume a team that beats another team is the better one. In the case of the Tommies and Johnnies, rivalry game or not, it matters that a made kick would have strongly changed our opinions on both teams. St. John's wouldn't have moved into the top 25, and the Tommies might have held on to their seven No. 1 votes.

On my ballot, Wesley dropped from No. 5 to No. 9, while the Tommies went from No. 2 to No. 10. Given the actual distance in points in the top 25, where No. 9 isn't that far from No. 6, I guess my opinion of the Tommies (or the Johnnies, No. 21 overall) isn't that different from the other 24 voters.

●  The AFCA released its first poll of the year, and given that it's the only other D-III ranking with a sampling of so many plugged-in voters -- 42 in all -- it's worth a peek. It's been well documented over the years that we feel the poll is nuanced -- taking into account strength of schedule, circumstances of games and more. The coaches, as coaches are wont to do, just care about wins.

The AFCA ranks four teams with losses -- St. Thomas, Wesley, Franklin (losses to Mount Union and FCS Butler) and Wittenberg (also to Butler). ranks five -- No. 24 Widener, which lost to Wesley, but the AFCA has Widener as the first team receiving votes.
Mount Union got 38 first-place votes from the coaches, with UMHB picking up four. Linfield, which got seven of's first place votes, had none.

The D3 first-place vote split was 13-7-5 Mount Union-Linfield-UMHB. Last week, it was 11-7-6-1, which means that St. Thomas's seven votes relocated by four to UMHB, two to Mount Union and one to Linfield -- in effect. I know that's not exactly how it happened, because I switched my No. 1 from Linfield to UMHB after Saturday.

●  What to do with the three ranked WIAC teams? We have Oshkosh 8, Platteville 9, Whitewater 12. The coaches have Platteville 6, Whitewater 7 and Oshkosh 9.  In the coaches' poll, Benedictine got 13 votes, Hope got nine, Juniata four. The NESCAC's Wesleyan got eight while Trinity only got two. Adrian, Hartwick, Catholic and Lake Forest all make appearances as well.

●  We learned last week that it isn't just Atomic Football who does predictions. Our old favorite, the Massey Ratings does too. But maybe the most fun sort is Massey's all-divisions-in-one-bucket rating that lists Mount Union at No. 263, one spot behind Yale and three behind Universite de Sherbrooke in Quebec. I don't know how much stock to put in the ranking, which has the NAIA's Carroll two spots ahead of D-II's Grand Valley State, but if you've ever wondered if College of the Desert is better than Middlebury, the answer is yes.

Also, No. 905 Alfred State brings up the rear for D-III in those ratings, 11 spots ahead of last-ranked Itasca CC at No. 916. Berry, although it hasn't scored a point in its history, is already the 801st-best college football program in the country.

Ryan Tipps

Ryan is's Senior Editor and began as National Columnist in fall 2014. He was the Around the Mid-Atlantic Columnist from 2007 to 2011, has worked on the preseason Kickoff publication since 2006 and has covered the Stagg Bowl in Salem for more than a decade. Ryan, a Wabash graduate, worked in newspapers as a writer and editor for 15 years before his current full-time job as editor of a magazine in Virginia.

2001-2013 columnist: Keith McMillan.

Previous Columns

November 19, 2015
Playoff picks, surprises, disappointments
Around the Nation has assembled a team of prognosticators for an annual look at who might surprise...
November 12, 2015
Between these four and the playoffs, an archrival stands
The final week of the regular season is full of great rivalry games and teams trying to clinch...
November 8, 2015
Snap Judgments: Muddying up the playoff picture
Yes, this was an actual Division III game from Saturday, with playoff implications. How did the...
November 5, 2015
Two-sport stars not ready to trade gridiron for court
Some of the hardiest of two-sport athletes in Division III play both football and basketball. The...
November 1, 2015
Snap judgments: Potent potential for Pool C
A couple of key losses this season have meant that some traditionally powerful teams are hoping to...
October 29, 2015
Clash of the Texas titans
It’s the first time since 2004 that Mary Hardin-Baylor and Hardin-Simmons have met so late in...
October 25, 2015
Snap judgments: Pools and conferences shaping up
This was certainly the kind of weekend that we needed to separate out some of the challengers. Now...
October 22, 2015
Linfield’s father figure
Sam Riddle's experience and maturity at quarterback for the Wildcats may well have its source in his...
October 18, 2015
Snap judgments: This week proves anything can happen
A few key wins by underdogs made sure some conference races were thrown wide open. Haven't beaten...
October 15, 2015
Re-ranking the conferences for 2015
Every August, Pat and Keith rank the conferences based on how they're expected to perform this...
October 11, 2015
Snap judgments: What we're learning
An instant classic proved that UW-Oshkosh was a legitimate contender. But how have Ryan Tipps' teams...
October 7, 2015
First-teamers square off
It was quite a show in Danville, Ky., where Hendrix and Centre met, bringing a pair of all-conferenc...
October 4, 2015
Snap judgments: Wet, and still wild
While a couple of games were cancelled and another was postponed, many games got played in various...
October 1, 2015
Starters in the making
Waiting is always going to be difficult. Some players sit for years behind a starter, preparing for...
September 27, 2015
Snap judgments: Frequently fixated
If you weren't at a game, or didn't have a vested interest in one particular team, Saturday was a...
September 24, 2015
Policing not only the streets, but also the backfield
Josh Brozek said a common question he gets asked is, “When do you sleep?” And considerin...
September 20, 2015
Snap judgments: Three teams to keep an eye on
Three weeks in is when the preseason predictions and expectations we had for the season really start...
September 17, 2015
D-III stacking up against the scholarship squads
When Division III teams take on the scholarship squads, a "moral victory" is not what...
September 13, 2015
Snap judgments: Beyond the blowouts
The big margins of victory grab a lot of eyeballs, and there's a lot of them, because there's a lot...
September 9, 2015
Change for the right reasons
At Augustana, Rowan and Emory & Henry, a little change has done the program some good. New...
September 6, 2015
Snap judgments: What does Week 1 tell us?
Around the Nation columnist Ryan Tipps weighs in on the first week's results, now that the teams...
 • More Division III football news releases

Other Columnists