/awards/all-americans/all-time

All-Time All-Americans

D3football.com's postseason All-America selections, listed by school:

Adrian
DE Mike Lewis, 2004 (3rd), 2005 (1st)
LB Taz Wallace, 2004 (3rd), 2006 (1st)

Albion
K Keith Debbaudt, 2000 (1st)
CB Chris Greenwood, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (3rd)
RB Clinton Orr, 2010 (3rd)

Albright
G Jonni Cassano, 2015 (HM)
S Matt Christ, 2007 (HM)
WR Nick Cushman, 2004 (1st)
ST Malik Gilmore, 2014 (1st)
S Drew Peterson, 2013 (2nd)
QB John Port, 2004 (HM)
WR Nate Romig, 2009 (3rd)
K Daniel Sobolewski, 2013 (3rd), 2015 (1st)

Alfred
LB Brenton Brady, 2004 (HM), 2005 (HM)
AP Nick Clark, 2010 (3rd)
LB Nick Clark, 2011 (3rd)
T Ryan DiFlavio, 2013 (3rd)
RB Vinson Hendrix, 2007 (3rd)
QB Tyler Johnson, 2016 (2nd)
LB A.J. LiCata, 2016 (3rd)
T Zach Morgan, 2010 (3rd)
C Sean Murphy, 2016 (HM)
DT Mike Raplee, 2010 (HM), 2011 (HM), 2012 (1st)
G David Sylvester, 2016 (2nd)
WR Ryan Thon, 2010 (HM)

Allegheny
OL Bill Andrews, 2000 (HM)
DL David Monaghan, 1999 (1st)
RB Shane Ream, 2000 (HM)
RET LaMarcus Thurman, 1999 (3rd)

Alma
DB Dustin Armstrong, 1999 (3rd)
WR Mark Boehms, 2002 (2nd)
WR Joe Cline, 2006 (HM)
DL Justin Harris, 1999 (1st), 2000 (2nd)
LB Anthony Sabatella, 2011 (HM)
DB David Simpson, 2002 (2nd)

Amherst
CB Fred Argir, 2009 (2nd)
DB Brian Daoust, 2000 (3rd)
S Jimmy Fairifield-Sonn, 2015 (3rd)
DT Kevin Ferber, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (1st)
DL Pat McGee, 2001 (HM)

Anderson
RB Denny Kimmel, 2005 (HM)
CB Jared Millikian, 2010 (3rd)

Augsburg
WR Muneer Al-Hameed, 2010 (HM)
RET Hakeem Bourne-McFarlane, 2013 (1st)
TE Adam Carl, 2012 (1st), 2013 (1st)
DB Jake Kern, 1999 (2nd)
LB Mike Matson, 2005 (3rd)
TE Josh Pronschinske, 2010 (HM)
P Nick Schlieman, 2003 (HM) , 2005 (HM)
WR Joey Sonnenfeld, 2015 (HM)
WR Royce Winford, 2007 (2nd), 2008 (1st)

Augustana
CB Tom Anthony, 2005 (1st)
RB David Chorney, 2001 (2nd)
K Mike Clark, 2003 (1st), 2004 (2nd)
OL MacKenzie Hay, 1999 (1st), 2000 (1st)
TE Chris Sally, 2000 (HM)
S Travis Shea, 2005 (HM)
OL J.D. Sheldon, 2000 (HM), 2001 (1st), 2002 (1st)
TE Jim Triveri, 2001 (3rd)
G Jon Verhelst, 2006 (3rd)
T Blaine Westemeyer, 2009 (1st)
LB Erik Westerberg, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (1st)
DL Tim Williams, 2001 (1st)
T Mike Zeifert, 2004 (2nd), 2005 (2nd)

Aurora
DB Marc Anderson, 1999 (HM)
DL Jeremy Benson, 2000 (HM)
DB Kip Daniels, 2001 (1st)
OL Bryon Megli, 2002 (2nd)
CB Matt Meyer, 2008 (2nd)
CB Robbie Parry, 2004 (HM)

Austin
RB Aaron Kernek, 2000 (HM)

Averett
RET Jeremy Dixon, 2009 (2nd)

Baldwin Wallace
RB Mark Anders, 2003 (3rd)
G Jason Cook, 2013 (3rd)
P Matt Harmon, 2013 (2nd)
S Greg Koch, 2003 (1st)
DE Ryan Lewis, 2005 (HM)
DE Nate Mitchell, 2003 (2nd)
P Kevin Soflkiancs, 2004 (1st), 2006 (1st), 2007 (2nd)

Bates
LB Frost Hubbard, 1999 (HM)

Benedictine
ST Jarrett Lecas, 2016 (1st)
S Jarrett Lecas, 2016 (HM)
DE Ben Lockton, 2011 (HM)
DL Pat Ryan, 2001 (1st), 2002 (2nd)

Berry
DE Mamadou Soumahoro, 2016 (2nd) 

Bethany
OL Geno Ochap, 2001 (HM)

Bethel
DB Hans Bengtson, 2001 (HM)
S Brandon Carr, 2006 (3rd), 2007 (1st)
T Mitch Elliot, 2011 (HM)
RB Logan Flannery, 2010 (1st)
DL Jon Foss, 2001 (HM)
T Bubba Friedlund, 2014 (2nd)
WR Mitch Hallstrom, 2013 (3rd)
RB Mike Johnson, 2001 (3rd)
QB Scott Kirchoff, 2003 (HM)
S Sam Lacy, 2003 (2nd)
RET Brandon Marquardt, 2014 (2nd)
LB Seth Mathis, 2012 (1st), 2013 (2nd)
DB Ben Matthews, 2000 (1st)
TE Drew Neuville, 2016 (3rd)
WR Joel Olson, 2001 (HM)
RB Phil Porta, 2004 (3rd), 2005 (2nd), 2006 (3rd)
OL Chico Rowland, 1999 (1st)
T Jeff Schmidt, 2013 (2nd)
T Ryan Wassink, 2006 (2nd)

Birmingham-Southern
RB Shawn Morris, 2011 (1st)

Bluffton
DE Ryan Aelker, 2015 (HM) 

Bowdoin
WR Pat Noone, 2009 (HM)

Bridgewater (Va.)
WR Tyler Beiler, 2010 (1st)
RB Davon Cruz, 2001 (1st)
OL Michael Day, 2001 (2nd), 2002 (3rd)
DT Lawrence Frierson, 2004 (3rd)
G Paul Getty, 2005 (2nd)
RET Jordan Hartman, 2014 (3rd)
S Adrian Herndon, 2004 (3rd)
QB Jason Lutz, 2001 (HM)
LB Gary Nelson, 2003 (HM)
LB Lonnie Parker, 2001 (2nd)
LB Jermaine Taylor, 2002 (3rd), 2003 (1st)
RET Marcus Washington, 2004 (2nd)
RB Marcus Washington, 2005 (2nd)
T Ranardo Whitaker, 2004 (HM)

Bridgewater State
G Jonathan Sullivan, 2003 (HM)

Brockport
RB Dan Andrews, 2015 (HM), 2016 (HM)
DT Tarik Bennett, 2015 (3rd)
DL Mike Condello, 2002 (1st)
T Cuyler Groth, 2007 (2nd)
LB Jason Johnson, 2001 (HM)
K Adam Lanctot, 2005 (HM)
RET Jeremy Lynch, 2002 (2nd)
TE Jamie Rother, 2002 (HM)
OL Josh Warner, 2000 (1st)

Buena Vista
LB Michael Irvin, 2004 (2nd)
P Chris Kemmerer, 2004 (HM)
OL Jeff Leng, 2001 (2nd)
K Carlos Martinez, 2000 (2nd), 2001 (1st)
LB Cody Pierce, 2006 (3rd)

Buffalo State
LB Marquis Artis, 2014 (3rd)
WR Derek Baker, 2000 (HM)
LB Jon Crumley, 1999 (1st)
DE Michael Holbok, 2003 (3rd)

Cal Lutheran
DE Jordan Barta, 2010 (HM)
DE Jacob Calderon, 2008 (HM)
K Jackson Damron, 2008 (HM), 2010 (2nd)
CB Victor Edwards, 2008 (3rd)
K Ryan Geisler, 1999 (3rd)
CB Justin Haulcy-Bateman, 2011 (1st)
DE Quinn Longhurst, 2004 (HM)
G Brent McNeil, 2010 (3rd)
WR Eric Rogers, 2012 (1st)
CB Luis Villavicencio, 2010 (2nd)

Capital
WR Derick Alexander, 2006 (2nd)
C Tom Doyle, 2003 (1st)
S Kyle Hausler, 2002 (3rd), 2004 (2nd), 2005 (1st)
WR Lewis Howes, 2005 (HM)
TE Dylan Kelly, 2006 (3rd)
C Josh Kinniard, 2006 (3rd)
TE Kive Kraft, 2005 (3rd)
QB Rocky Pentello, 2006 (1st)
G Shawn Papp, 2005 (1st)
T Adam Persing, 2007 (3rd)
DT Jonathan Spring, 2007 (3rd)
CB James Starks, 2007 (2nd)
LB Ron Swearingin, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (2nd), 2003 (1st)

Carleton
RB Erik Fisher, 2003 (HM)
DL Scott O'Reilly, 2001 (HM)
S Drew Ziller, 2008 (1st)

Carnegie Mellon
RB Sam Benger, 2015 (HM), 2016 (2nd)
S Drew Fitzmorris, 2015 (HM)
C Andrew Garibaldi, 2015 (HM)
DE Brian Khoury, 2015 (HM)
S Aaron Lewis, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (2nd)
P Matt Young, 2000 (3rd)
C J.P. White, 2006 (2nd)

Carroll
RET Brad Guettel, 2001 (HM)
DT Jake Zeh, 2008 (HM)

Carthage
RB Randal Baker, 2002 (3rd)
TE Bryan Bergman, 2007 (2nd)
CB Brandon Fox, 2004 (2nd)
P Tyler Funk, 2009 (2nd)
K Tyler Funk, 2010 (1st)
T Ryan Glassman, 2006 (3rd)
WR Jeff Koeneman, 2009 (2nd)
RB Dante Washington, 2003 (3rd), 2004 (3rd)

Case Western Reserve
LB Tom Brew, 2006 (3rd), 2007 (3rd)
QB Eli Grant, 2002 (3rd)
G Tony Opperman, 2009 (HM)
QB Dan Whalen, 2009 (1st)

Castleton State
WR Brandon Boyle, 2012 (3rd) 

Catholic
WR Nick Bublavi, 2005 (1st)
LB Brian Hee, 1999 (2nd)
WR Mike Hunter, 1999 (3rd)
OL Tim McCarthy, 1999 (3rd)
RB Andrew Notarfrancesco, 1999 (2nd)
CB Nick Olivero, 2008 (HM)
RET James Parker, 1999 (HM)
OL Dan Riely, 2000 (1st)

Central
LB Greg Altmeier, 2007 (3rd)
LB Austin Bonnema, 2002 (3rd)
QB Tim Connell, 2007 (HM)
CB Guy Dierikx, 2007 (3rd)
S Jacob Edleman, 2014 (HM)
T Ryan Johnson, 2005 (1st)
DB Chad Klein, 1999 (HM)
WR Sam Markham, 2016 (3rd)
G Nick Reed, 2006 (3rd)
DE Danny Samson, 2013 (1st)
LB Jeff Sanger, 2000 (3rd)
LB Mark Sanger, 2004 (3rd)
RB Vance Schuring, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (HM)
DL Justin Snyder, 2000 (1st)
DE Shane Wong, 2010 (3rd)

Centre
DB John Ortega, 2001 (HM), 2003 (3rd)
P Jordan Gay, 2012 (2nd)
LB Adam Hay, 2007 (HM)
T Ben Hume, 2011 (3rd)

Chapman
P Elias Deeb, 2016 (HM)
DB Dino Rossi, 2001 (1st)
OL Mark Shafer, 2001 (2nd)

Chicago
CB Vincent Beltrano, 2015 (1st)
TE Mike Healy, 2002 (2nd)
DT Scott Mainquist, 2014 (3rd)
LB Dan Philips, 1999 (1st), 2000 (2nd)
P Jeff Sauer, 2012 (4th) 

Christopher Newport
C Tommy Fitzgerald, 2004 (2nd)
RB Roland Hilliard, 2006 (HM)
RET Kentel Noel, 2010 (3rd)
RB Tunde Ogun, 2008 (1st)
CB Rob Rodriguez, 2006 (1st)

Claremont-Mudd-Scripps
CB Victor Bunce, 2015 (HM), 2016 (HM)

Coast Guard
S Steve Arguelles, 2006 (HM)
RET Mike Benson, 2000 (3rd)
P Jesse Harms, 2005 (3rd), 2006 (3rd), 2007 (3rd)
G Nick Hartmann, 2007 (3rd)
P Tyler Henning, 2015 (2nd)
TE Brian Whisler, 2003 (3rd)

Coe
RET Tom Breitbach, 2007 (HM)
DB Zak Gordon, 1999 (2nd)
RB Trevor Heitland, 2016 (2nd)
RB Fred Jackson, 2002 (2nd)
S Demetreus Johnson, 2012 (3rd)
DT Mitch Montgomery, 2013 (3rd)
P Scott Schara, 2001 (HM)
DT Matt Schmitz, 2014 (2nd)
CB Dylan Stepleton, 2016 (2nd)
DE Frank Weymiller, 2009 (HM), 2011 (2nd), 2012 (2nd)
G Nathan Yelton, 2012 (4th), 2013 (1st)

Colorado College
CB Drew Gallaugher, 2006 (3rd)
QB Jay Macias, 2003 (3rd)
TE Nolan Swett, 2007 (1st)

Concordia-Moorhead
DE Nate Adams, 2013 (3rd)
T Nick Dider, 2004 (HM)
T Tom Knowlton, 2012 (3rd)
CB Kenyon O'Brien, 2013 (HM)
WR Andrew Passanante, 2004 (HM)
CB Jordan Talge, 2004 (1st)
T Grant Weller, 2007 (HM)

Concordia (Ill.)
S Jarin Davis, 2009 (HM)

Concordia (Wis.)
RB Eric Hamilton, 1999 (3rd)
K Dan Winsey, 2009 (2nd)

Cornell
LB Chris Gustafson, 2007 (2nd)

Cortland
ST Travis Alvarez, 2016 (2nd)
RB Justin Autera, 2010 (HM)
WR John Babin, 2011 (HM), 2013 (HM)
G Billy Castro, 2010 (HM)
T Billy Castro, 2011 (2nd)
ST Lou Crispo, 2010 (2nd)
RB Andrew Giuliano, 2008 (HM)
DT Adam Haas, 2005 (1st), 2006 (1st)
DL John Longo, 2002 (HM)
CB Joe Lopez, 2010 (HM)
DE Ben Nagle, 2008 (3rd)
RET Dylan Peebles, 2014 (1st)
QB Dan Pitcher, 2011 (HM)
LB Jim Smith, 2008 (HM)
T Mike Wutzer, 2012 (4th) 

Curry
LB Sean Crowley, 2006 (HM)
C Kevin Kelleher, 2005 (3rd)
DT Tom Pinto, 2007 (3rd)

Defiance
WR Seth Dillon, 2007 (HM)
DL Edith Forestal, 2000 (HM)
S Kyle Longsdorf, 2010 (3rd)
CB Tony Sierra, 2013 (3rd) 

Delaware Valley
WR Rasheed Bailey, 2014 (1st)
WR David Carmon, 2004 (HM)
C Damien Ciecwisz, 2005 (1st)
S Carlo DeAngelo, 2003 (2nd)
LB Andrew Erby, 2004 (3rd)
LB Kyle Gesswein, 2009 (1st), 2010 (2nd)
DE Mike Jaskowski, 2010 (HM)
QB Adam Knoblauch, 2005 (3rd)
G John LaVelle, 2011 (3rd), 2012 (3rd)
LB Rashaad Lighty, 2015 (1st)
T Mike Long, 2009 (HM), 2010 (1st)
RET Taylor Ramos, 2003 (HM)
S John Robinson, 2012 (3rd)
DE Anthony Silver, 2006 (HM)
RB Chris Smallwood, 2014 (3rd)
T Ralph Stambaugh, 2008 (HM)

DePauw
G Lewis Brown, 2011 (2nd)
DE Dustin Hertel, 2006 (HM)
TE Tyler Kelley, 1999 (HM)
WR Alex Koors, 2009 (1st), 2010 (3rd)
RET Jamarcus Shephard, 2003 (1st)
RET Taylor Wagner, 2011 (HM)

Dickinson
LB Eric Dube, 2006 (3rd), 2007 (3rd)
DL Keith Fischer, 1999 (1st)
OL Terry Kohler, 1999 (3rd)
WR Pat O'Connor, 2008 (HM)
TE Ryan Stearrett, 2006 (HM)

Dubuque
WR Tyler Rutenbeck, 2013 (3rd)
RB Justin Spaulding, 2011 (3rd)
WR Michael Zweifel, 2009 (2nd), 2011 (1st)

East Texas Baptist
P Scott Verhalen, 2001 (1st), 2002 (1st), 2003 (2nd)
LB Greg Washington, 2003 (2nd)

Elmhurst
TE Andy Brogan, 2005 (HM)
TE Garrett Claxon, 2014 (HM)
T Charlie Homoky, 2012 (2nd)
RB Josh Williams, 2014 (2nd)
RB Scottie Williams, 2012 (1st)
LB Randy Wright, 2008 (3rd)

Emory and Henry
OL Michael Hughes, 1999 (2nd)
RB Caleb Jennings, 2009 (2nd)
RET Caleb Jennings, 2008 (HM)
DL Jelani Patterson, 2001 (3rd)
DB P.D. Peterson, 1999 (1st)
LB Devan Sproles, 2011 (HM)

Endicott
K Dylan Rushe, 2011 (2nd), 2013 (2nd)

FDU-Madison/FDU-Florham
DL Ken Freeman, 2001 (3rd)

Ferrum
OL Tim Boothe, 2001 (HM)
DL Toné Dancy, 2000 (2nd)
P T.J. Grzesikowski, 2008 (3rd), 2010 (2nd)
P Richard Harr, 1999 (HM)

Fitchburg State
S Brian Harnish, 2004 (HM)
K Treavor Smith, 2003 (2nd)

Framingham State
DT James Muirhead, 2012 (4th)
RB Melikke Van Alstyne, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (3rd)

Franklin
CB Zack Corpe, 2012 (3rd)
WR Kyle Linville, 2012 (4th), 2013 (1st)
DE Dan McManus, 2008 (3rd)
DL Josh McMillin, 2001 (3rd)
P Michael Parks, 2012 (3rd)
QB Kyle Ray, 2010 (1st)
QB Chad Rupp, 2007 (3rd), 2008 (2nd)
C Chad Schenkel, 2010 (3rd)
G Nick Schultz, 2011 (HM), 2012 (4th)

Franklin and Marshall
P Dan Eggertsson, 2004 (2nd)
WR Justin Salton, 2002 (HM), 2003 (HM)
RET Jordan Zackery, 2013 (3rd) 

Frostburg State
DE Kevin Culbert, 2005 (2nd)
DT Niles Scott, 2016 (HM)
DE William Sewell, 2016 (1st) 

Gallaudet
DE Adham Talaat, 2013 (HM)
CB Tony Tatum, 2012 (4th)

Gettysburg
LB Ryan Moore, 2001 (1st)
RET Nathan Smith, 2005 (HM)
RB Paul Smith, 1999 (1st)

Greenville
TE Zach Friedrich, 2009 (3rd)
TE Bryan Meier, 1999 (2nd), 2000 (1st)
WR Darryl DeShields, 1999 (HM)

Grinnell
TE Jeff Pedersen, 2000 (2nd)

Grove City
RB R.J. Bowers, 1999 (1st), 2000 (1st)

Guilford
P Christian Adams, 2004 (3rd)
WR Chris Barnette, 2006 (1st)
RET De'Eric Bell, 2015 (3rd)
CB JerMario Gooch, 2014 (2nd)
P Tyler Hunt, 2015 (3rd)
RET Chris McKinney, 2001 (1st)
QB Matt Pawlowski, 2015 (3rd)
WR Adam Smith, 2015 (3rd)
S Satiir Stevenson, 2013 (3rd), 2014 (1st)
WR Kevin Vaughn, 2008 (3rd)

Gustavus Adolphus
WR Matt Boyce, 2014 (3rd), 2015 (2nd)
RB Jeffrey Dubose, 2013 (HM)
RET Andy Traetow, 2000 (2nd)
S Joe Welch, 2008 (3rd)

Hampden-Sydney
S Bill Doody, 2009 (1st), 2010 (1st)
LB Trevor Ikwild, 2010 (2nd)
LB Tyler Ikwild, 2013 (3rd)
CB Zach Morgan, 2011 (3rd)
QB Nash Nance, 2013 (HM)
K David Prizzia, 2010 (3rd)
DE/DT Will Riggenbach, 2009 (HM), 2010 (3rd)
C Ben Rogers, 2011 (3rd)
DB Chris Scott, 2002 (3rd)
LB Andrew Sellers, 2009 (HM)
WR Conrad Singh, 2003 (2nd)
WR Drew Smith, 2007 (3rd)
WR Kyle Vance, 2011 (1st)
WR Holton Walker, 2013 (2nd), 2014 (2nd)

Hanover
LB Jason Allen, 2006 (HM)
WR Jeffrey Jourdan, 2002 (2nd)
CB Corry Stewart, 2009 (HM)

Hardin-Simmons
OL Thomas Anderson, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (1st)
T James Arnold, 2007 (HM)
RET Alex Bell, 2016 (2nd)
T Garet Black, 2004 (2nd)
WR Mychal Carillo, 2008 (2nd)
WR Reese Childress, 2016 (3rd)
T Tye Conry, 2005 (3rd)
T Brian Fitzgerald, 2008 (3rd)
P Nico Francino, 2014 (2nd), 2015 (1st), 2016 (1st)
LB Brent Gailey, 2004 (1st)
CB Will Galusha, 2004 (2nd), 2005 (1st)
TE Jerrad Grisham, 2008 (HM)
OL Gary Gutierrez, 1999 (2nd)
CB Alex Hansen, 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st)
DT Undra Hendrix, 2012 (2nd)
G Adam Hernandez, 2003 (2nd), 2004 (1st)
C Ryan Hunter, 2008 (1st)
DT Chris Jones, 2006 (2nd)
C Josh Knox, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (1st)
G Josh Maronski, 2016 (1st)
RET Jared May, 2004 (HM)
RB Lance Moore, 2004 (2nd)
OL Matt Morris, 2001 (2nd)
TE Matt Moskosky, 2002 (3rd)
G Chuck North, 2013 (2nd)
T Koby Parker, 2010 (HM)
RET Jessie Ramos, 2013 (2nd), 2015 (1st)
WR Jessie Ramos, 2015 (1st)
WR ZaVious Robbins, 2010 (2nd)
WR Kirk Rogers, 2000 (HM), 2001 (3rd)
QB Dustin Proctor, 2001 (2nd)
LB Jared Sanderson, 2001 (2nd)
C Travis Sugar, 2012 (3rd)
LB Cory Ward, 2016 (2nd)
S Matt Warnasch, 2008 (2nd)
DT Korey Zavala, 2015 (2nd) 

Hartwick
TE Greg Balcavage, 2000 (3rd)
WR Ryan Johnson, 2001 (3rd)
WR Jack Phelan, 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
DB Kory Schramm, 2002 (2nd)
WR Ryan Soule, 2002 (3rd)
DT Ben Tomaino, 2009 (HM)

Heidelberg
RB Cartel Brooks, 2012 (2nd), 2013 (1st), 2014 (3rd)
DT Austin Crow, 2016 (3rd)
WR Donteea Dye, 2014 (2nd)
DT Matt Grieves, 2009 (2nd)
TE Zach Hogya, 2015 (2nd)
T Austin Hunter, 2014 (2nd)
G Matt Kater, 2010 (2nd)
WR Demetrius Magee, 2016 (HM)
DT Ben Poirier, 2013 (2nd)
WR Mike Preston, 2010 (3rd)
T Quentin Rembert, 2013 (1st)
LB Craig Sykes, 2012 (3rd)
RB Germany Woods, 2011 (2nd)

Hendrix
RB Dayton Winn, 2016 (1st) 

Hobart
CB James Alexander, 2007 (3rd)
DT Ryan Aruck, 2008 (3rd)
P Dom Ancona, 2006 (HM)
G Alex Bell, 2003 (3rd), 2004 (1st)
RB Doug Blakowski, 2005 (HM)
LB Tim Booth, 2000 (HM), 2002 (HM)
DE Trye Coleman, 2012 (1st), 2013 (HM), 2014 (1st)
2014 Defensive Player of the Year
G Art Garvey, 2012 (3rd)
DL Rob Gould, 2000 (HM)
C Michael Green, 2013 (3rd)
LB Justin Hager, 2008 (2nd)
T Ali Marpet, 2014 (1st)
WR Brandon Shed, 2016 (1st)
G DeAndre Smith, 2014 (3rd)
ST Gabriel Smith, 2013 (2nd)
QB Shane Sweeney, 2016 (HM)
RB Steven Webb, 2013 (3rd)
LB Drake Woodard, 2011 (HM)
LB Devin Worthington, 2012 (2nd), 2013 (HM)

Hope
OL Tony Petkus, 1999 (HM)

Howard Payne
DL Harold Brooks, 1999 (3rd)
WR Walter Hays, 2002 (HM)
K Drew McMaster, 2001 (2nd)
DB Freeman Perry, 1999 (HM)
P Cole Schacherl, 2011 (2nd)
OL LaRon Slay, 2000 (3rd)
LB Mike Tates, 2000 (HM)
DL D'Andre Wilson, 2002 (HM)

Huntingdon
LB Zach Brownell, 2014 (HM)
DT D.J. Chappell, 2011 (HM), 2012 (1st)
DT Heath McCray, 2015 (HM)
ST Jeremy Murphy, 2014 (2nd) 
S Anthony White, 2015 (HM) 

Illinois College
WR Michael Jennings, 2008 (HM)

Illinois Wesleyan
CB Tyrell Bolden, 2015 (3rd)
T Travis Boothe, 2009 (3rd)
RET Eric Esch, 2004 (1st)
DL Jeff Heinzl, 2000 (1st)
P Matt Kussmann, 2014 (3rd)
LB Nick Nikolich, 2009 (2nd)
S Bo Osburn, 2007 (HM)

Ithaca
DB Ron Amato, 2000 (3rd)
P Brian Bicher, 2001 (3rd)
TE Ben Cary, 2014 (3rd)
RET Jason Chier, 2007 (3rd)
CB Jason Chier, 2008 (1st)
TE Vince Dargush, 2004 (1st)
OL Drew Davidson, 2001 (HM)
RET Kelly Gordon, 2006 (2nd)
G Chris Gray, 2008 (3rd)
OL Adam Grossman, 1999 (HM), 2000 (1st)
TE Jeff Irne, 1999 (1st)
TE Conor Mulkeen, 2001 (HM)
TE Jared Prugar, 2013 (2nd)
RET Dan Ruffrage, 2011 (3rd)
G Joe Scalice, 2005 (HM)
LB Matt Scalice, 2008 (1st)
RET Jordan Schemm, 2016 (HM)
DT Alex Shafiro, 2004 (2nd)
TE Brian Weverbergh, 2008 (3rd)

John Carroll
QB Tom Arth, 2001 (1st), 2002 (2nd)
DE Ken Bevington, 2007 (2nd)
DE Ray Brown, 2016 (HM)
LB Kevin Cope, 2014 (2nd)
LB Chris Cubero, 2002 (2nd)
S Jovon Dawson, 2016 (2nd)
T Victor DeBoer, 2004 (3rd)
T Dominic Ditirro, 2016 (3rd)
RET Aramis Greenwood, 2014 (HM)
CB Randy Greenwood, 2013 (2nd)
CB Michael Hollins, 2016 (1st)
G Anthony Latina, 2014 (2nd)
T Anthony Latina, 2015 (2nd)
T Devin Martin, 2011 (HM)
LB Mason McKenrick, 2016 (1st)
S Carlo Melaragno, 2008 (3rd)
QB Mark Myers, 2014 (HM)
DB Michael Mystic, 2001 (3rd)
OL Matt Payne, 2002 (2nd)
DB Tom Rini, 1999 (3rd)
RET David Ziegler, 1999 (2nd)

Johns Hopkins
C Chantz Anderson, 2016 (3rd)
S Matt Campbell, 2003 (3rd)
LB Keith Corliss, 2015 (1st)
C Ben Cranston, 2013 (1st)
G Colin Egan, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st)
T Armand Jennifer, 2012 (4th), 2013 (2nd)
RB Andrew Kase, 2009 (3rd)
K Alex Lachman, 2007 (3rd)
OL David Perna, 1999 (HM)
RB Jonathan Rigaud, 2012 (4th)
C Ed Rodger, 2010 (HM)
K Ben Scott, 2006 (3rd)
P Ben Scott, 2006 (2nd)
S Jack Toner, 2015 (2nd), 2016 (3rd)

Juniata
WR Matt Eisenberg, 1999 (3rd)
DT Brandon Felus, 2013 (HM) 

Kalamazoo
LB Eric Gerwin, 1999 (HM)
LB Jeremy Vanisacker, 2004 (2nd)

Kean
CB Austin Davis, 2015 (3rd)
T Chris Gould, 2008 (HM)
LB Darin Hungerford, 2016 (HM)
TE Jonathan Schmitt, 2015 (HM) 

Kenyon
LB Casey McConnell, 2002 (HM)

King's
OL Joe Corbett, 2001 (3rd)
DL Rubin Doster, 2000 (HM)
OL Bob Fehr, 2002 (3rd)
S Craig Haywood, 2006 (3rd)
DL Chris Keene, 2002 (2nd)
RB Damon Saxon, 2000 (1st)
DL Steven Wilson, 2001 (1st), 2002 (1st)

Knox
CB Seth Koph, 2003 (3rd)

LaGrange
LB Andre Carter, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (2nd)
K Will Jeffcoat, 2012 (3rd)

La Verne
RB Travis Sparks-Jackson, 2015 (2nd) 

Lake Forest
DE David Bleitner, 2003 (HM)
RET Alex Pasiewicz, 2016 (1st)
ST R.J. Pompey, 2016 (3rd)
LB Casey Urlacher, 2002 (2nd) 
RB Joey Valdivia, 2016 (3rd) 

Lakeland
DE David Benton, 2005 (HM)
LB Ryan Van de Loo, 2005 (HM)

Lebanon Valley
DB Sean Berwager, 2000 (HM)
OL Ryan Brennan, 2002 (HM)
LB Frank Gaffney, 2013 (2nd)
G Tyler Good, 2015 (2nd)
RB Ben Guiles, 2011 (HM)
RET Pete Henning, 2000 (HM)
DE Cory Horner, 2011 (3rd)
G Brendan Kozub, 2013 (2nd)
LB Todd Lipp, 1999 (3rd)
TE Scott Marek, 2003 (1st)
T Sean Tetreault, 2009 (2nd)

Lewis and Clark
TE Shawn Evans, 2011 (1st)

Linfield
OL Daryl Agpalsa, 2002 (1st)
WR Casey Allen, 2004 (1st), 2005 (1st)
G Jordan Barnes, 2011 (HM)
CB Kyle Belcher, 2015 (2nd)
K Scott Birkhofer, 2007 (HM), 2008 (1st)
QB Aaron Boehme, 2010 (2nd)
WR George Carter, 2004 (3rd)
QB Brett Elliott, 2004 (1st), 2005 (1st)
2005 Offensive Player of the Year
S Drew Fisher, 2009 (HM), 2010 (2nd), 2011 (1st)
LB Dom Forrest, 2012 (2nd), 2013 (1st)
DT Jeremy Girod, 2014 (HM)
S Jordan Giza, 2014 (HM)
RET Brandon Hazenberg, 2004 (3rd)
DE Eric Hedin, 2010 (1st)
T Aaron Heston, 2010 (2nd)
DE Alex Hoff, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st)
DE Brynnan Hyland, 2012 (1st)
QB Mickey Inns, 2012 (4th)
RET Kennedy Johnson, 2015 (2nd)
CB Kennedy Johnson, 2016 (3rd)
DB Ray Lions, 2002 (1st)
G Jake Lucey, 2005 (3rd)
G Scott Millenbach, 2009 (1st)
G Stephen Nnabue, 2016 (3rd)
LB Brandon Olson, 2005 (2nd)
S Josh Ort, 2005 (1st)
C Jeremy Patrick, 2014 (3rd)
C Eric Pitassi, 2015 (1st)
QB Sam Riddle, 2015 (2nd), 2016 (1st)
2016 Offensive Player of the Year
DB Alex Rix, 2000 (1st)
RB David Russell, 2002 (1st)
T Steven Schultz, 2013 (1st), 2014 (HM)
DT Tyler Steele, 2011 (3rd), 2013 (1st)
G Drew Wert, 2012 (2nd)
P James Wilson, 2003 (1st)
S Keanu Yamamoto, 2015 (3rd) 

Loras
DT Ross Dillavou, 2005 (1st)
RB Alex McGrew, 2008 (HM)
DB Chris Miller, 2001 (3rd)

Louisiana College
LB Beau Brewer, 2014 (3rd)
C Hunter Feibel, 2013 (2nd)
CB Ira Jewitt, 2014 (1st)
T Matt Miller, 2003 (2nd)
WR D'Mario Parker, 2012 (2nd)
T Brandon Porche, 2014 (3rd)
CB Kendale Rayford, 2008 (2nd)
P Tim Willett, 2015 (HM) 

Luther
LB Kyle McGivney, 2010 (1st), 2011 (2nd)
G Jon Stavast, 2006 (HM), 2007 (1st)
RB Tyler Sherden, 2007 (HM)

Lycoming
S Ray Bierbach, 2010 (HM), 2011 (3rd)
DB Sean Graf, 2000 (3rd)
DT Dwight Hentz, 2013 (HM)
WR Ricky Lannetti, 2003 (3rd)
DE Anthony Marascio, 2011 (2nd)
DE Sean McGinley, 2003 (2nd)
T Matt Mendola, 2003 (HM)
P John Shaffer, 2000 (HM)
DE Ryan Yaple, 2007 (HM)
S Tanner Troutman, 2013 (1st) 

Macalester
K Auburn Jimenez, 2010 (HM)
DL Andrew Porter, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (HM)

MacMurray
DL Jon Jones, 1999 (HM)

Maine Maritime
RB Jim Bower, 2009 (2nd), 2010 (2nd)
RB Don Thibodeau, 2005 (3rd)

Marietta
RB Kenneth Sasu, 1999 (3rd)
RB Roger Walker, 2016 (HM) 

Mary Hardin-Baylor
DT Haston Adams, 2016 (2nd)
S Eric Allen, 2014 (2nd)
QB LiDarral Bailey, 2012 (2nd)
OL Michael Bradford, 2000 (HM)
RB Justin Bryson, 2004 (2nd)
C Matt Bush, 2004 (1st)
DT Terrance Carroll, 2006 (HM)
G Michael Coles, 2011 (2nd), 2012 (1st)
CB Brodrick Crain, 2013 (1st)
RB Quincy Daniels, 2010 (2nd)
C Dustin Davis, 2009 (3rd)
DE William Dewease, 2007 (HM)
DT Silvio Diaz, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (1st)
LB Jerrell Freeman, 2006 (1st), 2007 (1st)
2007 Defensive Player of the Year
T Connally Fuller, 2016 (1st)
P Hunter Hamrick, 2005 (1st)
OL Ryan Harris, 2002 (1st)
G Jordan Hataway, 2007 (2nd)
LB Eric Henri, 2008 (1st)
G Josh Holt, 2013 (3rd)
C Tyler Hykel, 2007 (3rd)
QB Blake Jackson, 2016 (3rd)
G Broderick Jenkins, 2015 (2nd), 2016 (1st)
S Cody Jones, 2013 (3rd)
LB Javicz Jones, 2011 (2nd), 2012 (1st)
2012 Defensive Player of the Year
LB Josh Kubiak, 2005 (2nd)
S Josh Kubiak, 2006 (1st)
G Josh Littlejohn, 2008 (1st)
T Sam Maxie, 2012 (2nd)
LB Preston Meyer, 2000 (HM), 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)
RB Markeith Miller, 2016 (3rd)
S Baylor Mullins, 2016 (1st)
K Alan Munoz, 2008 (3rd)
K Joel Munoz, 2007 (2nd)
RET Geoff Myles, 2010 (HM)
K Zach Newcomb, 2006 (1st)
T Jeff Oliver, 2003 (2nd), 2004 (1st)
K Jacob O'Neill, 2015 (HM)
CB Brett Parker, 2009 (2nd)
G Bryan Ramirez, 2004 (3rd)
LB Keith Reineke, 2016 (2nd)
RET Shaun Rochon, 2002 (3rd)
DE Teidrick Smith, 2014 (HM), 2015 (2nd), 2016 (1st)
2016 Defensive Player of the Year
DE Korey Steward, 2013 (2nd)
T Max Taylor, 2010 (2nd)
LB Pierce Thedford, 2015 (2nd)
RB Jarvis Thrasher, 2007 (2nd)
AP Bryson Tucker, 2009 (1st)
S Derrick Williams, 2007 (2nd), 2008 (1st)
RET P.J. Williams, 2005 (2nd)
RB Darius Wilson, 2011 (HM)
T Caleb Woodall, 2006 (HM), 2007 (1st)
DE Keith Zunker, 2004 (3rd)

Maryville (Tenn.)
DT Zach Capehart, 2014 (HM)
LB Kyle Chewning, 2009 (HM)
G Rance Hightower, 2013 (HM)
DT Colby Townsend, 2005 (HM)

Mass-Dartmouth
T Pat Sullivan, 2016 (HM) 

McDaniel/Western Maryland
DL Aaron Bartolain, 2000 (HM)
DB Marvin Deal, 1999 (1st)
QB Ron Sermarini, 1999 (HM)
LB Matt Wilchinski, 2002 (3rd)
DB Jason Wingeart, 2001 (2nd)

McMurry
CB Desmond Baker, 2010 (3rd)
TE Delfonte Diamond, 2011 (3rd)
S Will Morris, 2010 (HM), 2011 (2nd)

Menlo
QB Zamir Amin, 2000 (3rd), 2001 (HM)
OL Charlie Dutra, 2002 (HM)
WR Nate Jackson, 2000 (1st), 2001 (1st)
RET Jihad Mahasin, 2006 (3rd)

Merchant Marine (Kings Point)
RB David McNeal, 2002 (3rd)
K Geoff Troy, 2005 (1st)

Methodist
DL Quincy Malloy, 2001 (2nd)

Middlebury
TE Billy Chapman, 2011 (HM), 2012 (2nd)
C Brendan Kelly, 2008 (3rd)
T Ryan Moores, 2012 (1st)
LB Erik Woodring, 2007 (HM)

Millikin
K Andy Beals, 2003 (3rd)
G Jon Hart, 2004 (2nd)

Millsaps
LB Will Hawkins, 2009 (1st), 2010 (3rd)
RET Chris Jackson, 2006 (1st)
QB Juan Joseph, 2008 (3rd)
LB Matt O'Bryant, 2002 (HM), 2003 (2nd)
G John Shivers, 2008 (3rd)
DT Casey Younger, 2007 (HM)

Mississippi College
WR Jake Allen, 2007 (2nd)
CB Jarrad Craine, 2011 (1st)
LB Quartez Ashmore, 2009 (3rd)
TE Renard Ellis, 2009 (1st)
P Wilson Hillman, 2000 (1st)
G Josh Lankford, 2009 (2nd)
P Jonathan Russell, 2005 (2nd)
CB Keith Villafranco, 2012 (1st) 

MIT
RB DeRon Brown, 2008 (2nd), 2009 (HM)
G James Olenik, 2008 (HM)
G Elliot Tobin, 2014 (HM) 

Monmouth
G James Allen, 2011 (3rd)
WR Mike Blodgett, 2011 (HM)
G Kolton Koch, 2016 (2nd)
G Josh Kotecki, 2008 (2nd)
QB Alex Tanney, 2009 (2nd), 2011 (2nd)
G Dan Wingler, 2004 (HM)

Montclair State
LB Dan Avento, 2011 (HM)
DL Carlos Bolanos, 2000 (3rd)
CB C.J. Conway, 2013 (2nd), 2014 (HM)
RB Chris D'Andrea, 2011 (2nd)
CB Dominique Dixon, 2009 (2nd)
K Vin Doffont, 2006 (HM)
S Chad Faulcon, 2011 (3rd)
S Eric Gargiulo, 2014 (3rd)
LB Cornell Hunt, 2008 (HM)
G Frank Iachette, 2004 (3rd)
DL Kevin Kelly, 1999 (3rd)
RB Ron Lewis, 1999 (HM)
LB Omar Lucas, 2001 (1st)
WR Eric Magrini, 2001 (HM)
DT Chris Merkle, 2009 (3rd)
LB Ray Meyer, 2003 (3rd)
S Bill Shimko, 2015 (2nd)
OL Anthony Vitale, 2001 (1st)

Moravian
CB John Paniekiewsky, 2003 (HM)
DB Jarrod Pence, 2001 (2nd)
DE Allen Petros, 2011 (3rd)

Mount Union
QB Rob Adamson, 2002 (HM)
OL Tom Bauer, 1999 (1st)
G Derek Blanchard, 2006 (1st), 2007 (1st)
QB Zac Bruney, 2004 (3rd)
QB Kevin Burke, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st)
2013 Offensive Player of the Year
DE Lambert Budzinski, 2010 (2nd)
DL Matt Campbell, 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)
K Rodney Chenos, 2001 (3rd)
S Jesse Clum, 2004 (1st)
WR Jasper Collins, 2012 (1st)
T Caleb Crowl, 2009 (1st)
RET Chris Denton, 2012 (1st)
DE Charles Dieuseul, 2011 (1st)
LB Charles Dieuseul, 2012 (1st)
DT Antoine Dillard, 2003 (2nd)
DL Matt Domin, 1999 (3rd)
C Mitch Doraty, 2015 (2nd), 2016 (1st)
S Nick Driskill, 2011 (1st), 2012 (1st)
2011 Defensive Player of the Year
C Brett Ekkens, 2011 (1st)
CB Daryl Ely, 2008 (3rd)
DT Matt Fechko, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (2nd)
S Alex Ferrara, 2011 (HM)
T Michael Frank, 2014 (3rd)
G Michael Frank, 2015 (HM)
LB Anthony Frate, 2003 (3rd)
WR Pierre Garcon, 2006 (1st), 2007 (1st)
OL Jason Gerber, 1999 (HM), 2000 (1st)
LB Mike Gibbons, 2005 (1st)
DB Alex Grinch, 2001 (3rd)
G Samy Guerrero, 2010 (HM)
DE James Herbert, 2008 (1st), 2009 (3rd)
CB Tre Jones, 2014 (3rd), 2015 (2nd)
T Brooks Jenkins, 2016 (1st)
DE Johnny Josef, 2004 (2nd)
DB Chris Kern, 2001 (1st), 2002 (1st)
LB Sam Kershaw, 2009 (1st), 2010 (HM)
OL Larry Kinnard, 2002 (1st), 2003 (1st)
RB Nate Kmic, 2006 (1st), 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
2006 Offensive Player of the Year
2008 Offensive Player of the Year
WR Randell Knapp, 2003 (3rd)
C Mac Knisely, 2012 (2nd)
S Alex Kocheff, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st)
S Matt Kostelnik, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
DT Tom Lally, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st)
2015 Defensive Player of the Year
T Jason Lewis, 2005 (1st), 2006 (1st)
LB Judd Lutz, 2009 (3rd)
OL Ed Malone, 2001 (1st)
WR Adam Marino, 1999 (2nd), 2000 (1st)
G Matt Mattox, 2012 (1st)
DT Pat McCullough, 2007 (1st)
S Drew McClain, 2009 (3rd)
WR Luc Meacham, 2013 (HM)
QB Greg Micheli, 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
G Brent Miller, 2003 (HM)
TE Kyle Miller, 2009 (2nd), 2010 (2nd)
CB Mike Miller, 2003 (3rd)
DE Joe Millings, 2009 (2nd)
RB Bradley Mitchell, 2016 (1st)
RB Chuck Moore, 2001 (1st)
WR Roman Namdar, 2015 (3rd)
RB Logan Nemeth, 2015 (2nd)
LB Jesse Pearson, 2000 (3rd)
LB Jason Perkins, 2001 (3rd)
RB Dan Pugh, 2002 (1st)
QB Kurt Rocco, 2009 (3rd)
K Ed Ruhnke, 2014 (2nd)
OL Bill Rychel, 2000 (2nd)
OL Eric Safran, 2006 (2nd, G), 2007 (1st, C)
CB Isaiah Scott, 2012 (2nd)
QB Taurice Scott, 2015 (HM)
WR Cecil Shorts, 2008 (3rd), 2009 (1st), 2010 (1st)
2009 Offensive Player of the Year
QB Gary Smeck, 1999 (3rd), 2000 (2nd)
LB Hank Spencer, 2014 (HM), 2015 (2nd)
LB Shaun Spisak, 2004 (1st)
DE Justen Stickley, 2006 (1st)
T Luke Summers, 2008 (1st)
T Antonio Tate, 2011 (2nd), 2012 (1st)
DT Mike Vidal, 2016 (1st)
CB Ross Watson, 2005 (2nd)
DT Matt Williamson, 2008 (HM), 2009 (1st)
DT Buddy Wolf, 2005 (3rd)

Mount St. Joseph
RB James Clay, 2012 (3rd)
DE Matt Lawless, 2004 (2nd)
G Anthony Walsh, 2009 (HM)

Muhlenberg
DB Mike Burke, 2000 (HM)
RET Joshua Carter, 1999 (1st), 2000 (1st)
RB John DeLuca, 2008 (3rd)
TE Matt Johnson, 2007 (3rd)
RET Nick Lamb, 2016 (3rd)
TE Michael Long, 2013 (3rd), 2014 (1st)
LB Dan McCall, 2005 (3rd)
LB Patrick McDonough, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (3rd)
T Chris Radomski, 2003 (3rd)
LB Matt Rathbun, 2008 (3rd)
K Chris Reed, 2002 (HM)

Muskingum
LB Chaney Fulton, 2014 (HM)
LB Alex Thomas, 2011 (3rd)

North Carolina Wesleyan
DT LeeRon Boykin, 2007 (HM), 2009 (HM)
RET Dwayne Hollis, 2012 (2nd) 

North Central
G Kyle Antos, 2010 (1st)
S Timothy Bellazzini, 2006 (HM)
DT Peter Bulandr, 2011 (1st)
T Josh Delancy, 2009 (3rd)
S Shane Dierking, 2013 (1st)
T Joe Fehrle, 2016 (HM)
TE Kyle Fiedorowicz, 2011 (2nd)
DE Valente Garza, 2010 (3rd)
G Don Kasper, 2007 (3rd)
CB Josh Mitchell, 2011 (HM)
LB Lenny Radtke, 2004 (2nd), 2005 (2nd)
LB Nick Slezak, 2013 (3rd)
WR Tyke Spencer, 2005 (3rd)
QB Spencer Stanek, 2013 (2nd)
DE Alex Tripp, 2013 (2nd)
LB Matt Wenger, 2008 (2nd), 2010 (1st)
2010 Defensive Player of the Year
T Jace Werkheiser, 2013 (HM)

Norwich
K Long Ding, 2011 (3rd)

Oberlin
DE Clay Eaton, 2012 (3rd)
LB Sam Hobi, 2001 (HM)
CB Quammie Semper, 2003 (2nd)

Occidental
LB Mike Bryant, 2003 (HM), 2004 (HM)
QB Andy Collins, 2006 (3rd)
G Sam Emerson, 2008 (2nd)
P Alex Groh, 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st), 2009 (1st)
P Cory Ohnesorge, 2002 (HM), 2003 (3rd)
DL Kevin Watson, 2002 (3rd)
DE Alex Wertheimer, 2009 (2nd)

Ohio Northern
G Andrew Benchic, 2009 (2nd)
K J.R. Cipra, 2000 (HM)
RB Brent Donley, 2009 (3rd), 2010 (HM)
CB Wes Hostetler, 2005 (3rd)
RET Wes Hostetler, 2005 (3rd)
DT Jake Fallis, 2008 (2nd)
S Rusty Midlam, 2005 (3rd)
WR Devon Price, 2015 (2nd)
RB Jamal Robertson, 1999 (HM), 2000 (2nd)
C Kevin Thomas, 2005 (HM)
DE Jason Trusnik, 2004 (1st), 2006 (3rd)
LB Lenny Trusnik, 2007 (2nd)
P Steve Vagedes, 1999 (2nd)
DB Randy VanTilburg, 2000 (2nd)

Ohio Wesleyan
TE Calvin Cagney, 2012 (3rd)
DT Cisco Clervoix, 2005 (2nd)
DB Mike Fowler, 1999 (1st)
OL Jeff Hollway, 2002 (2nd)
DL Ike Reid, 1999 (2nd)

Olivet
P Ryan Anderson, 2016 (2nd)
DE Ryan Armstrong, 2014 (3rd)
P Ryan Patten, 2007 (HM), 2008 (HM)
S Michael Terranova, 2007 (3rd)

Otterbein
WR Trey Fairchild, 2011 (3rd)
T Andy Fries, 2008 (3rd)
TE Jeff Gibbs, 2001 (1st)
S Dominic Jones, 2010 (1st)
RET Dominic Jones, 2010 (1st)
CB Micheaux Robinson, 2004 (HM)
DE Patrick Seesholtz, 2012 (4th) 

Pacific
LB Jack Perez, 2016 (2nd) 

Pacific Lutheran
DB Seth Berghoff, 2001 (2nd)
LB Casey Carlson, 2002 (HM), 2003 (1st)
DE Andrew Eisentrout, 2007 (3rd)
OL Andrew Finstuen, 1999 (3rd)
RB Anthony Hicks, 1999 (2nd)
OL Josh Hostetter, 1999 (2nd)
QB Chad Johnson, 2000 (1st)
LB Tim Lax, 1999 (HM)
OL Trevor Roberts, 2001 (3rd)
DT Mychael Tuiasosopo, 2012 (2nd) 

Plymouth State
T Zac Duval, 2009 (HM)

Randolph-Macon
DB Bobby Akers, 2002 (HM)
WR Sean Eaton, 1999 (1st)
RB Will McGhee, 2013 (HM)
P Tracy Murden, 2013 (3rd)
WR Earl Peoples, 2009 (HM)
DE Tiko Williams, 2003 (HM)
K Seth Yurgel, 2016 (3rd) 

Redlands
DE Brock Arndt, 2008 (2nd)
DL Scott Foster, 1999 (HM)
DT Wil Goff, 2003 (HM)
K Kevin Grady, 2012 (2nd)
WR Chad Hustead, 1999 (HM)
P Sean Lipscomb, 2002 (2nd)
G Travis McBride, 2009 (3rd)
QB Danny Ragsdale, 1999 (2nd)
TE Melvin White, 1999 (3rd)
DB Jeff Thomas, 2002 (1st)
OL Clint Treadway, 2000 (3rd)

Rhodes
RET Hays Mathis, 2001 (3rd)

Ripon
RB Luke Hagel, 2002 (HM)
DB Nate Kok, 2000 (1st)
S Josh Kraemer, 2009 (HM)

Rose-Hulman
DT Adam Helmerich, 2006 (3rd)
OL Daniel Schwartz, 2001 (HM)
DT Jake Vieck, 2004 (3rd)

Rowan
DE Chris Alvarez, 2013 (3rd)
OL Jarryn Avery, 1999 (1st)
T Scott Blum, 2004 (1st)
LB Darren Dungee, 2015 (3rd)
LB John Gavlick, 1999 (1st)
DE Keith Heimerl, 2006 (2nd)
DE Matt Hoffman, 2010 (2nd)
RB Withler Marcelin, 2014 (HM)
LB Mike McClain, 2004 (HM)
DB Clinton Tabb, 1999 (1st), 2000 (HM), 2001 (HM)
LB Dominic Tomeo, 2003 (HM)
DL Gerrit Tosh, 2002 (2nd)
DE Randy Tosh, 2005 (3rd)
DL Tim Watson, 1999 (HM)
CB Dawaine Whetstone, 2006 (2nd)
DL Cornelius White, 1999 (2nd)

RPI
TE Jon Branche, 2004 (HM), 2005 (1st)
WR Jon Branche, 2006 (2nd)
K Eric Byrne, 1999 (2nd)
WR Flynn Cochran, 2003 (2nd)
QB Dan Cole, 2003 (2nd)
S Mike Defilippi, 2003 (HM)
K Andrew Franks, 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st)

Salisbury
TE Kyle Acker, 2003 (2nd)
G Riley Cannon, 2016 (3rd)
CB Andre Carter, 2013 (1st)
DE Jarrell Chandler, 2007 (2nd), 2008 (1st)
LB Brad DeHaven, 2004 (1st)
P Kyle Hamby, 2013 (1st), 2014 (HM)
CB Brandon Hudson, 2009 (1st)
G Alex Smith, 2011 (1st)
CB Byron Westbrook, 2004 (3rd), 2006 (3rd)
RET Byron Westbrook, 2006 (HM)

Salve Regina
DT Hayden Stanton, 2013 (3rd)
CB Phil Terio, 2012 (3rd)
RET Phil Terio, 2012 (4th) 

Sewanee
K Ben Tuck, 2002 (2nd)

Shenandoah
G Lamont Moore, 2003 (3rd), 2004 (HM)

Simpson
P Mike Donnenwerth, 2002 (3rd)
WR Dusty Kain, 2003 (HM)
DE Jason Ripke, 2004 (1st), 2005 (3rd)
DT Luke Stover, 2008 (3rd)
CB Kyle Westphal, 2003 (2nd)

Southwestern
DE Justin Broussard, 2016 (2nd) 

Springfield
RET Jarred Burrell, 2009 (3rd)
G Brian Dewey, 2003 (1st)
G Adam Feit, 2006 (1st)
LB Max Nacewicz, 2015 (3rd)
OL Matt Sallila, 2000 (2nd)
QB Chris Sharpe, 2006 (HM)
K Greg Switaj, 2002 (1st)
OL Kevin Vacca, 2001 (HM)

St. John Fisher
QB Tim Bailey, 2010 (HM)
T Corey Balcerzak, 2010 (3rd), 2011 (1st)
K Will Bean, 2004 (1st)
LB Andy Episcopo, 2009 (HM)
WR Noah Fehrenbach, 2005 (HM)
T Brennan Fortune, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
DE Brad Keem, 2003 (3rd)
LB Gene Lang, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (1st)
RB Jason Meyers, 2003 (HM)
RB Mark Robinson, 2004 (1st), 2006 (2nd)
CB Troy Sant, 2011 (2nd)
G John Schultz, 2005 (2nd)
CB Steve Stepnick, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
G James Thomas, 2013 (1st)
S Dave Vosburgh, 2011 (2nd)

St. John's
P Phil Barry, 1999 (1st)
RET Josh Bungum, 2015 (HM)
G Ross Carlson, 2014 (HM)
DE Damien Dumonceaux, 2005 (1st)
2005 Defensive Player of the Year
RET Blake Elliott, 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)
WR Blake Elliott, 2002 (1st), 2003 (1st)
CB Bobby Fischer, 2012 (1st)
DT Jason Good, 2004 (2nd)
DT Nick Gunderson, 2006 (HM), 2007 (2nd)
LB Carter Hanson, 2015 (HM), 2016 (3rd)
DL Jeremy Hood, 2001 (1st), 2002 (1st), 2003 (1st)
LB Beau LaBore, 1999 (2nd), 2000 (2nd)
K Jimmie Mattson, 2012 (4th)
LB Cam McCambridge, 2002 (1st), 2003 (3rd)
DE Kevin McNamara, 2006 (3rd)
LB Brandon Novak, 1999 (3rd)
DB Jason Pflipsen, 2002 (2nd)
C Andrew Salvato, 2007 (HM)
OL Chris Salvato, 2000 (2nd)
DT Kyle Schroeder, 2009 (3rd), 2010 (1st)
RB Sam Sura, 2014 (1st), 2015 (3rd)
DT Peyton Thiry, 2015 (HM)
DT Ryan Weinandt, 2003 (3rd)

St. Lawrence
DT Chyron Brown-Wallace, 2015 (1st), 2016 (1st)
DT Gerard Bryant, 2008 (1st), 2009 (1st)
TE Mitch Gallagher, 2016 (HM)
CB Leondre Simmon, 2014 (HM), 2015 (1st)

St. Norbert
DE Jay Arndt, 2007 (3rd)
ST Dan Egan, 2013 (3rd)
S Ryan Grandlic, 2016 (HM)
LB Jerimiah Janssen, 1999 (3rd), 2000 (1st), 2001 (1st)
CB Joe Masciopinto, 2003 (1st)
TE Seth Schussler, 2003 (HM)

St. Olaf
DE Brian Albrecht, 2011 (HM)
WR Horace Gant, 2007 (3rd)

St. Scholastica
S Alec French, 2013 (HM) 
LB Alex Mangan, 2015 (HM)
K Mike Theismann, 2014 (HM) 

St. Thomas
LB Jesse Addo, 2015 (HM), 2016 (3rd)
CB Michael Alada, 2016 (1st)
T Dan Chapman, 2011 (3rd)
LB Tony Danna, 2011 (1st)
TE Charlie Dowdle, 2015 (1st)
S Brady Ervin, 2010 (3rd)
T Will Hilbert, 2015 (HM), 2016 (2nd)
DE Ayo Idowu, 2012 (3rd)
C Curtis James, 2011 (2nd), 2012 (1st)
S Chinni Oji, 2012 (4th)
C Josh Ostrue, 2008 (2nd), 2009 (2nd), 2010 (1st)
RB Jordan Roberts, 2015 (1st)
2015 Offensive Player of the Year
T David Simmet, 2015 (1st)
WR P.J. Theisen, 2007 (HM)
RB Colin Tobin, 2011 (3rd)
LB Andrew Ubbelhode, 2005 (1st)
RET Fritz Waldvogel, 2011 (2nd)
WR Fritz Waldvogel, 2011 (2nd)
RB Ben Wartman, 2009 (1st)
LB Tremayne Williams, 2012 (4th)
DT Ryan Winter, 2015 (3rd), 2016 (HM)
C T.J. Woodrow, 2014 (2nd) 

Stevenson
S Austin Tennessee, 2016 (1st) 

Stillman
LB Brenden Givan, 2000 (3rd)

Sul Ross State
WR Lee Carothers, 2012 (4th)
RB Dominique Carson, 2012 (1st) 
DT Zack Roberson, 2016 (3rd) 

SUNY-Maritime
K Diogo Dietrich, 2014 (3rd) 

Susquehanna
WR Mark Bartosic, 2003 (1st)
P Bobby Eppleman, 2008 (2nd)
S John Lunardi, 2008 (2nd)
DB Antonio Nash, 1999 (2nd), 2002 (HM)
RB Dave Paveletz, 2009 (HM)
OL Randy Zook, 1999 (HM)

Swarthmore
OL Mat Rapoza, 2000 (2nd) See Washington and Lee

TCNJ
LB Nick Bricker, 2011 (2nd), 2013 (HM)
DT Joe King, 2007 (2nd)
P Tyler Olsson, 2011 (1st)
DT Scott Paterson, 2003 (HM)

Texas Lutheran
RB Marquis Barolle, 2014 (HM)
K Allen Cain, 2011 (1st), 2012 (1st)
TE Matt Ross, 2004 (3rd)
K Holt Storrie, 2004 (HM), 2005 (2nd)
G Kendall Wilkerson, 2014 (3rd) 

Thiel
WR Brandon Chambers, 2005 (1st)
DB Kennard Davis, 2002 (HM), 2004 (3rd)
T Dave Hendricks, 2005 (HM)

Thomas More
OL Matthew Atkins, 2002 (3rd), 2003 (3rd)
CB Zach Autenreib, 2009 (3rd), 2012 (2nd)
LB Mark Carlisle, 2006 (HM)
RB Will Castleberry, 2000 (2nd)
RB Domonique Hayden, 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st)
DT Tyler Owens, 2010 (1st)
LB Brad Steinmetz, 2009 (2nd)

Trine/Tri-State
LB Courtney Pearson, 2008 (3rd), 2007 (HM)
QB Eric Watt, 2010 (3rd)

Trinity (Conn.)
OL Jared Carillo, 2002 (HM)
OL Michael Carucci, 2000 (3rd)
S Aaron Goldstein, 2004 (HM)
S Rae Haynes, 2012 (4th)
TE Chris Hunt, 2010 (3rd)
G Michael Robinson, 2007 (2nd)
K Eric Sachse, 2016 (HM) 

Trinity (Texas)
DT Dustin Allen, 2005 (HM), 2006 (3rd)
K Garrett Biel, 2009 (3rd)
RB Jeremy Boyce, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (2nd)
QB Michael Burton, 1999 (1st)
OL David Coney, 1999 (1st)
LB Ryan Deck, 1999 (2nd)
OL James Flowers, 2002 (3rd)
C Tommy Ford, 2004 (HM)
QB Roy Hampton, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (1st)
WR Jason Hunt, 2002 (3rd)
DE Luke Packard, 2016 (3rd)
OL Bill Smith, 2001 (1st)
DE Jarrod Smith, 2003 (1st)
P Kyle Trella, 2009 (3rd), 2011 (HM)
WR Jerheme Urban, 2002 (1st)
LB John Paul Visosky, 2000 (1st)

Tufts
OL Adam Collette, 2002 (HM)
DT Chris Lawrence, 2004 (HM)
S Tom Tassinari, 2009 (HM)
RET Mark Tilki, 2003 (3rd)
OL Mike Willey, 2001 (3rd)
DB Evan Zupancic, 2002 (2nd)

Union
WR Steve Angiletta, 2005 (2nd)
RB Tom Arcidiacono, 2005 (1st), 2006 (2nd)
T Dustin Connolly, 2006 (3rd)
K Cliff Eisenhut, 2003 (HM)
WR Justin Gallo, 2011 (2nd)
G Mark Herrington, 2010 (3rd)
LB Noah Joseph, 2012 (4th)
T Jim Masso, 2005 (2nd)
CB Chris Nappi, 2005 (3rd)
K Andrew Ruffo, 2001 (HM)
DL Joshua Stinehour, 2001 (2nd)

Upper Iowa
RB Mike Hatten, 2000 (3rd)

Ursinus
DB Eric Cowie, 2000 (2nd)
DB Mike Dale, 2001 (HM)
RB Shearrod Duncan, 2001 (2nd)

Utica
T Zach Hunnewell, 2014 (HM)
WR Jeremy Meier, 2012 (3rd) 
K Thomas Woodburn, 2015 (2nd)
DE Nick Woodman, 2015 (3rd)

UW-Eau Claire
DL Austin Crow, 2001 (HM)
C Paul Santi, 2013 (HM)
OL Bob Schmidt, 2000 (HM), 2001 (2nd)
S Brent Tieri, 2005 (3rd)
S Dave Wicklund, 2007 (3rd)

UW-La Crosse
WR Scott Burnoski, 2004 (3rd)
CB Derek Dreher, 2011 (2nd)
G Randy Gyllin, 2007 (HM)
P Christian Hallingstad, 2011 (3rd), 2012 (1st)
LB Drew Kiefer, 2008 (HM)
RB Andrew Mocadlo, 2003 (2nd)
DB Brian Portilia, 2000 (HM)
CB Steve Teeples, 2006 (1st)
DB Jeremy Unertl, 2001 (3rd)

UW-Oshkosh
C Eric Allen, 2011 (HM)
T Vincent Basile, 2016 (3rd)
S Austin Blashka, 2013 (2nd)
DB Nick Carlson, 2002 (3rd)
LB Reese Dziedzic, 2016 (1st)
S Johnny Eagan, 2016 (2nd)
CB Tim Filter, 2012 (2nd)
LB Taylor Goodman, 2012 (4th)
RB Andy Moriarty, 2007 (2nd)
RB Cole Myhra, 2012 (2nd), 2013 (2nd)
T Brandon Peter, 2012 (3rd)
P Nate Ray, 2014 (1st)
TE Joe Sommers, 2014 (2nd)
C Ben Strehlow, 2012 (4th)
DE Andrew Thompson, 2012 (4th)
T Sam Versnik, 2015 (1st)
QB Nate Wara, 2012 (1st)
2012 Offensive Player of the Year 

UW-Platteville
P Brad Abraham, 2001 (2nd)
WR Dan Arnold, 2016 (1st)
CB Rob Austin, 2013 (HM)
LB Andrew Belken, 2015 (3rd)
G Jayson Eddy, 2014 (2nd)
QB John Kelly, 2013 (3rd)
DE Andrew Robinson, 2015 (3rd)
K Tony Smidl, 2009 (HM)
LB Jacob Zilbar, 2014 (1st) 

UW-Stevens Point
TE Ross Adamczak, 2004 (2nd)
P Jared Jenkins, 2010 (1st)
DE Aaron Karlen, 2014 (3rd)
TE Brad Kalsow, 2008 (2nd)
QB Scott Krause, 2003 (1st)
DL Paul Schmitt, 2001 (2nd)
S Zach Vallafskey, 2014 (2nd)
DT Brad Vickroy, 2008 (1st)

UW-Stout
DE Marcus Ball, 2008 (2nd), 2009 (1st)
DL Jeff Hazuga, 2000 (2nd)
OL Jeff Hutter, 2000 (3rd)
OL Ben Knepper, 2002 (2nd), 2003 (1st)
K Evan Larsen, 2005 (3rd)
P Kevin McCulley, 2000 (2nd)
TE Patrick Mengelkoch, 2010 (1st)
DB Eric Moe, 2001 (2nd)
QB Nick Ohman, 2004 (2nd)
K Drew Pearson, 2016 (1st)
DB Tyrone Rhone, 2002 (1st)
CB Joe Seep, 2005 (2nd)
LB Jamie Spielman, 2002 (1st)
G Dustin Tervelt, 2008 (HM)
C Josh Towner, 2003 (HM)
CB Kendall Wade, 2009 (HM)

UW-Whitewater
T Logan Allemand, 2011 (1st)
C Brent Allen, 2007 (2nd)
LB Greg Arnold, 2011 (1st)
RB Justin Beaver, 2005 (1st), 2006 (1st), 2007 (1st)
2007 Offensive Player of the Year
QB Matt Behrendt, 2014 (2nd)
CB Trey Bell, 2004 (3rd)
QB Matt Blanchard, 2011 (3rd)
DT Casey Casper, 2011 (2nd)
C Garth Coats, 2009 (HM)
RB Levell Coppage, 2008 (3rd), 2009 (1st), 2010 (1st), 2011 (1st)
2010 Offensive Player of the Year
2011 Offensive Player of the Year
LB Justin Dischler, 2014 (2nd), 2015 (2nd)
QB Jeff Donovan, 2009 (HM)
CB Ben Farley, 2007 (2nd)
DT Zach Franz, 2014 (1st)
C Mark Gawronski, 2010 (2nd)
CB Brady Grayvold, 2014 (1st)
DT Wesley Hicks, 2010 (3rd)
RET Justin Howard, 2013 (HM)
QB Justin Jacobs, 2005 (HM)
G Austin Jones, 2016 (HM)
K Eric Kindler, 2013 (HM)
DT Ryan Kleppe, 2005 (3rd), 2006 (1st)
2006 Defensive Player of the Year
LB Cole Klotz, 2013 (1st)
2013 Defensive Player of the Year
T Tony Koepnick, 2015 (3rd), 2016 (2nd)
WR Jake Kumerow, 2013 (HM), 2014 (1st)
2014 Offensive Player of the Year
CB Vince Mason, 2016 (2nd)
CB Marcus McLin, 2013 (3rd), 2014 (3rd)
DT Ryan Ogrizovich, 2007 (1st)
LB Lane Olson, 2010 (HM)
G Conner Peters, 2014 (1st)
LB A.J. Raebel, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (2nd)
G Brady Ramseier, 2005 (1st)
RB Jordan Ratliffe, 2015 (3rd)
LB Jace Rindahl, 2008 (1st)
T Max Sakellaris, 2005 (3rd), 2006 (1st)
K Jeff Schebler, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st), 2008 (2nd), 2009 (1st)
TE Pete Schmitt, 2006 (2nd)
G Mike Sherman, 2008 (1st)
C Spencer Shier, 2015 (3rd)
CB Troney Shumpert, 2008 (HM), 2009 (3rd)
G Lucas Skibba, 2013 (HM)
RET Derek Stanley, 2003 (2nd)
WR Derek Stanley, 2006 (3rd)
LB Kyle Supianoski, 2009 (2nd)
DT Brandon Tamsett, 2016 (2nd)
T Robbie Ustruck, 2010 (1st)
G Matt Weber, 2009 (1st), 2010 (1st)
CB Ryan Wenkman, 2012 (4th)
DE Anthony White, 2008 (HM)
LB Robb Widuch, 2005 (1st)
S Ryan Winske, 2015 (1st)
DB Jake Wolter, 2000 (1st)
K Chad Wurth, 2002 (3rd)

Wabash
S Austin Brown, 2016 (3rd)
DE Cody Buresh, 2013 (1st), 2014 (2nd)
RET Wes Chamblee, 2009 (HM), 2011 (1st)
S Addrian Frederick, 2009 (1st)
LB CJ Gum, 2011 (1st)
DT Blair Hammer, 2003 (1st)
QB Russ Harbaugh, 2005 (2nd)
T Evan Isaacs, 2009 (2nd)
DT Darryl Kennon, 2008 (2nd)
T Weston Kitley, 2010 (HM)
ST Jonathan Koop, 2010 (1st)
DT Tyler McCullen, 2015 (2nd)
C Tony Neymeyier, 2008 (HM)
LB Adrian Pynenberg, 2005 (HM), 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
LB Nate Scola, 2013 (HM)
TE Ryan Short, 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)
P Cameron Soboleski, 2013 (HM)
RB Mason Zurek, 2015 (1st)

Wartburg
T Chris Brinkmeier, 2014 (1st)
CB Spencer Capitani, 2014 (2nd)
OL Joel Demro, 2001 (3rd)
DB David Devine, 1999 (2nd), 2000 (2nd)
DB/WR Cody Kelley, 2003 (1st)
DL Vince King, 2002 (3rd), 2003 (1st)
P Robby Salmon, 2010 (HM)
QB Logan Schrader, 2014 (3rd)
DL Anthony Souhrada, 1999 (1st)
LB Blake Suckow, 2010 (3rd)
CB Josh VanDenHul, 2010 (HM)
G Jeff Voreis, 2003 (2nd)
G Chase Wilhelms, 2015 (1st) 

Washington and Jefferson
WR Alex Baroffio, 2013 (2nd)
WR Craig Besong, 2009 (3rd)
WR Todd Fry, 2001 (2nd)
G Chris Hickey, 2005 (3rd), 2006 (2nd)
G Matt Houy, 2007 (HM)
WR Aaron Krepps, 2004 (2nd), 2005 (3rd)
OL Jason Matusik, 1999 (3rd), 2000 (3rd)
S Frank Pilato, 2003 (1st), 2004 (2nd)
WR Ryan Silvis, 2000 (3rd)
RET Roger Snyder, 2002 (HM)
QB Bobby Swallow, 2007 (2nd), 2008 (HM)
C John Wanner, 2014 (HM) 
WR Jesse Zubik, 2016 (2nd) 

Washington and Lee
CB Will Dyson, 2016 (3rd)
G John Fitzgibbons, 2011 (1st)
RB Luke Heinsohn, 2012 (4th)
T Connor Hollenbeck, 2013 (HM)
T Michael LaSala, 2015 (3rd)
S Jake Pelton, 2011 (HM)
OL Mat Rapoza, 2001 (1st), 2002 (3rd)
RET Stuart Sitterson, 2005 (1st)

Washington U.
CB Brandon Brown, 2010 (1st)
DB Kevin Dym, 1999 (3rd)
K Jonathan Feig, 2000 (3rd)
K Alex Hallwachs, 2015 (3rd)
WR Kevin Hammarlund, 2016 (HM)
CB Quincy Marting, 2015 (HM)
DL James Molnar, 2000 (2nd)
TE Matt Page, 2016 (2nd)
CB Joe Rizzo, 2005 (HM)
DL Tim Runnalls, 1999 (2nd)

Waynesburg
RET Scott Cree, 2008 (3rd)
DE Mike Czerwien, 2007 (1st)
RB Robert Heller, 2007 (HM)
TE Adam Moses, 2012 (4th)
DT Darryl Moore Jr., 2011 (3rd)
ST Kyle Richey, 2014 (HM) 

Wesley
LB Mike Asiedu, 2010 (1st)
RET Larry Beavers, 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
S Aaron Benson, 2009 (2nd)
QB Joe Callahan, 2015 (1st)
WR Michael Clarke, 2006 (HM)
G Brian Cranmer, 2012 (2nd)
DE Devin Hardy, 2012 (2nd)
T Dave Erdman, 2007 (2nd)
T Matthew Gono, 2015 (HM)
LB Sosthene Kapepula, 2012 (2nd), 2013 (3rd), 2014 (1st)
WR Steve Koudossou, 2014 (HM)
TE Jon Lanouette, 2007 (HM), 2008 (1st)
LB Sean Matthews, 2008 (2nd)
DE Chris Mayes, 2009 (3rd), 2010 (1st), 2011 (1st)
TE Sean McAndrew, 2009 (HM)
OL Sean McCullin, 1999 (2nd)
QB Shane McSweeny, 2011 (1st)
S Jared Morris, 2012 (1st), 2013 (HM)
S Rocky Myers, 2003 (HM), 2004 (1st)
LB Jeff Morgan, 2010 (HM)
WR James Okike, 2015 (HM)
RB Mike Pennewell, 2007 (3rd)
DE Aamir Petrose, 2014 (2nd)
DE Bryan Robinson, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
DT Payton Rose, 2014 (2nd)
G Matthew Schmidt, 2015 (3rd)
WR Bryce Shade, 2015 (1st), 2016 (2nd)
DB Andre Summers, 1999 (HM), 2000 (3rd)
CB Chet Turner, 2007 (HM)
DT Mike Ward, 2009 (2nd)
G Anthony West, 2010 (2nd)
DL Walt Wright, 1999 (3rd)

Wesleyan
RB Shea Dwyer, 2010 (3rd)
WR Matt Perceval, 1999 (2nd)

Western Connecticut
DL Greg Boucher, 2000 (3rd)
OL Nerijus Gelazauskas, 2002 (HM)
K Adam Kennett, 1999 (HM)
RB Octavias McKoy, 2013 (2nd)
OL Jason Plachcinski, 2000 (2nd)

Western New England
CB Obi Etuka, 2016 (HM)
AP Mike Graham, 2011 (3rd)

Westfield State
DL Tim Corr, 2001 (HM)
CB Josh Mathieu, 2009 (1st)
P Chris Stengel, 2009 (HM)
DL Josue Zamora, 2001 (3rd), 2002 (3rd)

Westminster (Mo.)
DB Mike Lindhardt, 2002 (HM)
WR Scott Pingel, 1999 (1st)

Westminster (Pa.)
DT Ryan Chmura, 2005 (2nd)
DT Tony Ventresco, 2004 (HM)

Wheaton
LB Caleb Ashby, 2016 (1st)
K Chris Baughman, 1999 (1st)
C Spencer Clark, 2014 (1st)
LB Adam Dansdill, 2014 (2nd), 2015 (1st)
C Brian Dini, 2004 (3rd)
DT Brandon Dykstra, 2012 (4th)
G Peter Gibson, 2015 (3rd)
RB Garrett Granberg, 2004 (HM)
DE Chase Greenlee, 2016 (HM)
G James Hoxworth, 2003 (1st)
WR Mark Hiben, 2012 (2nd)
CB Pete Ittersagen, 2006 (HM), 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
RET Pete Ittersagen, 2007 (2nd), 2008 (2nd)
DL Justin Knapp, 2002 (3rd)
C Kyler Kregel, 2016 (2nd)
LB J.D. Leman, 2000 (1st)
TE Zach Lindquist, 2016 (1st)
DL Dane Lundgren, 1999 (HM), 2002 (2nd)
WR Brad Musso, 2004 (2nd)
DL Drew Pearson, 1999 (2nd)
DB John Peays, 1999 (3rd)
RB Dan Price, 2003 (2nd)
K Scott Roche, 2011 (HM)
T Jesse Scott, 2008 (1st)
T Matt Snebold, 2015 (2nd)
DE Andy Studebaker, 2006 (1st)

Whitworth
TE Michael Allan, 2005 (2nd), 2006 (1st)
RB Adam Anderson, 2008 (2nd)
DL Sky Blake, 2000 (1st)
QB Joel Clark, 2006 (2nd)
K Cameron Collings, 2004 (3rd)
TE Nick Kiourkas, 2015 (3rd)
CB Ryan Marshall, 2005 (HM)
S Jay Tully, 2007 (2nd)

Widener
CB Orlando Brown, 2007 (HM)
WR Michael Coleman, 2000 (2nd), 2001 (1st)
DE Byron Cooper, 2016 (3rd)
WR Anthony Davis, 2013 (1st), 2014 (HM)
DT Thomas DeMoss, 2003 (3rd)
S Todd Fairlie, 2005 (HM)
DT Tyler Glover, 2014 (3rd)
LB Brandon Harper, 2014 (3rd)
DB T.J. Hess, 2001 (1st)
DE Brandon Jones, 2015 (2nd)
WR Jim Jones, 2000 (2nd)
RET Laquan Robinson, 2010 (2nd)
S Sean Titus, 2014 (3rd) 

Wilkes
CB Mike Ferriero, 2006 (HM)
LB Kyle Follweiler, 2005 (3rd), 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)
S Kevin Gerhart, 2010 (2nd)
T Jason Holloway, 2003 (3rd)
G Jordan Purdy, 2006 (HM)
DL Jermaine Richardson, 2000 (3rd)
DT Anthony Serafin, 2006 (2nd)
RB Brett Trichilo, 2003 (1st), 2004 (HM)

Willamette
G/T Brandon Bennett, 2005 (HM), 2006 (HM), 2007 (3rd)
T Jake Forshey, 2008 (2nd)
RB Dylan Jones, 2014 (2nd)
C Billy Joe Murray, 2003 (2nd)
LB Jack Nelson, 2014 (1st)
S Cody Pastorino, 2012 (2nd)
LB Ralph Pineda, 2009 (3rd)
T Morgan Smith, 2003 (HM)
WR Merben Woo, 2008 (2nd)

William Paterson
CB Leer Biddle, 2010 (1st)

Williams
WR Jon Drenckhahn, 2006 (3rd)
ST Scott Farley, 2002 (1st)
LB Graham Goldwasser, 2003 (2nd)
G Chris Kenney, 2006 (HM)
T John Szawlowski, 2008 (2nd)

Wilmington
DB Antonio Broadnax, 2000 (2nd)
WR Jonathan Cain, 2000 (3rd)
S Chad Otte, 2006 (1st)
QB Adam Ryan, 2000 (HM)
DT Brandon Tisdale, 2003 (2nd), 2004 (1st)

Wittenberg
T Aaron Coeling, 2013 (3rd)
RB Casey Donaldson, 2000 (3rd)
P Will Gingery, 2016 (3rd)
RB Daniel Grove, 2001 (HM), 2002 (HM)
C Dillon Hollin, 2009 (1st)
LB Dustin Holmes, 2016 (HM)
T Brad Kassner, 2004 (3rd)
WR Josh McKee, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (3rd)
RB Tristan Murray, 2006 (3rd)
OL Mark Sunderman, 2000 (HM)
DE Eddie Vallery, 2009 (1st)
2009 Defensive Player of the Year

Wooster
ST Shawn Bowman, 2013 (HM)
OL Ryan Dansak, 1999 (3rd)
T Rick Drushal, 2005 (HM)
LB Seth Duerr, 2000 (2nd)
CB Nick Hajjar, 2002 (3rd), 2003 (HM)
ST Brandon James, 2014 (3rd)
DT Joe Kearney, 2004 (1st)
P Matt Mahaffey, 1999 (3rd)
DE Andy Mizak, 2004 (HM)
OL Chad Peterman, 1999 (2nd)
OL Jon Spragg, 2002 (2nd)
RB Tony Sutton, 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st)
DT Dan Terhune, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (2nd)
G Jim Wallace, 2004 (2nd)

Worcester State
RET Graham Asum, 2012 (3rd)
DE Bryan Narcisse, 2014 (HM)
DL Russ Watson, 2000 (1st)

WPI
ST Ernie Mello, 2011 (1st)
LB Brian Murtagh, 2016 (HM) 

Nov. 18: All times Eastern
Final
Husson 23, at Springfield 21
Video Video Box Score Recap Photos
Final
at Berry 34, Huntingdon 20
Video Video Box Score Recap Photos
Final
at Delaware Valley 35, Western New England 0
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at Brockport 66, Plymouth State 0
Video Box Score Recap Photos
Final
Frostburg State 35, at Wittenberg 7
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at Mount Union 21, Washington and Lee 0
Video Box Score Photos
Final
at Wesley 45, RPI 27
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at Washington and Jefferson 31, Johns Hopkins 28
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at Trine 63, Monmouth 24
Video Box Score Photos
Final
at Mary Hardin-Baylor 50, Chapman 6
Video Box Score Recap
Final
Case Western Reserve 28, at Illinois Wesleyan 0
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at UW-Oshkosh 63, Lakeland 0
Video Box Score Recap Photos
Final
at St. Thomas 47, Eureka 8
Video Photos Video Recap Photos Box Score
Final - OT
at Wartburg 35, Franklin 34
Video Preview Box Score Live stats Photos
Final
at North Central (Ill.) 17, St. John's 7
Video Box Score Recap
Final
at Linfield 27, Hardin-Simmons 13
Box Score Photos
Nov. 25: All times Eastern
12:00 PM
Wesley at Brockport
Video Preview Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Case Western Reserve at Mount Union
Video Preview Preview Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Frostburg State at Washington and Jefferson
Video Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Husson at Delaware Valley
Video Live stats
1:00 PM
Berry at St. Thomas
Video Live stats Live stats Audio Audio
1:00 PM
North Central (Ill.) at UW-Oshkosh
Video Live stats Live stats Audio
1:00 PM
Linfield at Mary Hardin-Baylor
1:00 PM
Trine at Wartburg
Video Live stats
Nov. 19: All times Eastern
Final
at Alfred 29, Stevenson 16
@ University of Delaware
Video Box Score Recap
Nov. 25: All times Eastern
12:00 PM
Wesley at Brockport
Video Preview Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Case Western Reserve at Mount Union
Video Preview Preview Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Frostburg State at Washington and Jefferson
Video Live stats Audio
12:00 PM
Husson at Delaware Valley
Video Live stats
1:00 PM
Berry at St. Thomas
Video Live stats Live stats Audio Audio
1:00 PM
North Central (Ill.) at UW-Oshkosh
Video Live stats Live stats Audio
1:00 PM
Linfield at Mary Hardin-Baylor
1:00 PM
Trine at Wartburg
Video Live stats