All-Am
|
1999
|
2000
|
2001
|
2002
|
2003
|
2004
|
2005
|
2006
|
2007
|
2008
|
2009
|
2010
|
2011
|
2012
2005 All-Americans
Offensive Player of the Year: Brett Elliott,
Sr., Linfield
Defensive Player of the Year: Damien Dumonceaux,
Sr., St. John's
Coach of the Year: Bob Berezowitz,
UW-Whitewater
| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Brett Elliott, Sr., Linfield | Russ Harbaugh, Sr., Wabash |
| RB | Justin Beaver, So., UW-Whitewater | Phil Porta, Jr., Bethel |
| RB | Tom Arcidiacono, Jr., Union | Marcus Washington, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) |
| WR | Nick Bublavi, Sr., Catholic | Steve Angiletta, Jr., Union |
| WR | Casey Allen, Sr., Linfield | Brandon Chambers, Sr., Thiel |
| TE | Jon Branche, Jr., RPI | Michael Allan, Jr., Whitworth |
| T | Jason Lewis, Jr., Mount Union | Jim Masso, Sr., Union |
| G | Brady Ramseier, So., UW-Whitewater | John Schultz, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| C | Damien Ciecwisz, Sr., Delaware Valley | Josh Knox, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
| G | Shawn Papp, Sr., Capital | Paul Getty, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) |
| T | Ryan Johnson, Sr., Central | Mike Zeifert, Sr., Augustana |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Damien Dumonceaux, Sr., St. John's | Bryan Robinson, So., Wesley |
| DT | Ross Dillavou, Sr., Loras | Ryan Chmura, Sr., Westminster (Pa.) |
| DT | Adam Haas, Jr., Cortland State | Cisco Clervoix, Sr., Ohio Wesleyan |
| DE | Mike Lewis, Sr., Adrian | Kevin Culbert, Sr., Frostburg State |
| LB | Mike Gibbons, Sr., Mount Union | Gene Lang, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| LB | Andrew Ubbelhode, Sr., St. Thomas | Brandon Olson, Sr., Linfield |
| LB | Robb Widuch, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Lenny Radtke, Sr., North Central |
| CB | Tom Anthony, Sr., Augustana | Ross Watson, Sr., Mount Union |
| S | Kyle Hausler, Sr., Capital | Josh Kubiak, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| S | Josh Ort, Sr., Linfield | Aaron Lewis, Jr., Carnegie Mellon |
| CB | Will Galusha, Jr., Hardin-Simmons | Joe Seep, Sr., UW-Stout |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Geoff Troy, Fr., Kings Point | Holt Storrie, So., Texas Lutheran |
| P | Hunter Hamrick, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jonathan Russell, Jr., Mississippi College |
| RET | Stuart Sitterson, Fr., Washington and Lee | P.J. Williams, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Adam Knoblauch, Sr., Delaware Valley | Justin Jacobs, Jr,. UW-Whitewater |
| RB | Vance Schuring, So., Central | Doug Blakowski, Jr., Hobart |
| RB | Don Thibodeau, Sr., Maine Maritime | Denny Kimmel, Jr., Anderson |
| WR | Aaron Krepps, Sr., Washington and Jefferson | Lewis Howes, Sr., Capital |
| WR | Tyke Spencer, Sr., North Central | Noah Fehrenbach, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| TE | Kive Kraft, Sr., Capital | Andy Brogan, Sr., Elmhurst |
| T | Max Sakellaris, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Dave Hendricks, Sr., Thiel |
| G | Jake Lucey, Jr., Linfield | Joe Scalice, Sr., Ithaca |
| C | Kevin Kelleher, Sr., Curry | Kevin Thomas, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| G | Chris Hickey, Jr., Washington and Jefferson | Brandon Bennett, So., Willamette |
| T | Tye Conry, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Rick Drushal, Jr., Wooster |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Jason Ripke, Sr., Simpson | Ryan Lewis, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace |
| DT | Ryan Kleppe, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Colby Townsend, Jr., Maryville |
| DT | Buddy Wolf, Sr., Mount Union | Dustin Allen, Jr., Trinity (Texas) |
| DE | Randy Tosh, So., Rowan | David Benton, Sr., Lakeland |
| LB | Mike Matson, Jr., Augsburg | Brenton Brady, Sr., Alfred |
| LB | Dan McCall, Sr., Muhlenberg | Adrian Pynenberg, So., Wabash |
| LB | Kyle Follweiler, So., Wilkes | Ryan Van de Loo, Sr., Lakeland |
| CB | Chris Nappi, Sr., Union | Ryan Marshall, So., Whitworth |
| S | Rusty Midlam, Sr., Ohio Northern | Todd Fairlie, Sr., Widener |
| S | Brent Tieri, Sr., UW-Eau Claire | Travis Shea, Sr., Augustana |
| CB | Wes Hostetler, Sr., Ohio Northern | Joe Rizzo, Sr., Washington U. |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Evan Larsen, Sr., UW-Stout | Adam Lanctot, Jr., Brockport State |
| P | Jesse Harms, So., Coast Guard | Nick Schlieman, Sr., Augsburg |
| RET | Wes Hostetler, Sr., Ohio Northern | Nathan Smith, Sr., Gettysburg |
