All-Am
|
1999
|
2000
|
2001
|
2002
|
2003
|
2004
|
2005
|
2006
|
2007
|
2008
|
2009
|
2010
|
2011
|
2012
2003 All-Americans
| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Scott Krause, Sr., UW-Stevens Point | Dan Cole, Sr., RPI |
| RB | Tony Sutton, Jr., Wooster | Dan Price, Sr., Wheaton |
| RB | Brett Trichilo, Jr., Wilkes | Andrew Mocadlo, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| WR | Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's | Conrad Singh, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| WR | Mark Bartosic, Sr., Susquehanna | Flynn Cochran, Sr., RPI |
| TE | Scott Marek, Sr., Lebanon Valley | Kyle Acker, Sr., Salisbury |
| OT | Larry Kinnard, Sr., Mount Union | Jeff Oliver, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| OG | Brian Dewey, Jr., Springfield | Jeff Voreis, Sr., Wartburg |
| C | Tom Doyle, Sr., Capital | Billy Joe Murray, Sr., Willamette |
| OG | James Hoxworth, Sr., Wheaton | Adam Hernandez, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
| OT | Ben Knepper, Sr., UW-Stout | Matt Miller, Sr., Louisiana College |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Jarrod Smith, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Nate Mitchell, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace |
| DT | Blair Hammer, Sr., Wabash | Antoine Dillard, Sr., Mount Union |
| DT | Vince King, Sr., Wartburg | Brandon Tisdale, Jr., Wilmington |
| DE | Jeremy Hood, Sr. St. John's | Sean McGinley, Sr., Lycoming |
| LB | Jermaine Taylor, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) | Greg Washington, Jr., East Texas Baptist |
| LB | Ron Swearingin, Sr., Capital | Graham Goldwasser, Sr., Williams |
| LB | Casey Carlson, Sr., Pacific Lutheran | Matt O'Bryant, Sr., Millsaps |
| CB | Joe Masciopinto, Sr., St. Norbert | Kyle Westphal, Jr., Simpson |
| S | Greg Koch, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace | Sam Lacy, Sr., Bethel |
| S | Frank Pilato, Jr., Washington and Jefferson | Carlo DeAngelo, Sr., Delaware Valley |
| CB | Alex Hansen, Jr., Hardin-Simmons | Quammie Semper, Sr., Oberlin |
| DB/WR | Cody Kelley, Sr., Wartburg | |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Mike Clark, Jr., Augustana | Treavor Smith, So., Fitchburg State |
| P | James Wilson, Jr., Linfield | Scott Verhalen, Sr., East Texas Baptist |
| RET | Jamarcus Shephard, Jr., DePauw | Derek Stanley, Fr. UW-Whitewater |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Jay Macias, Sr., Colorado College | Scott Kirchoff, Sr., Bethel |
| RB | Mark Anders, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace | Erik Fisher, Sr., Carleton |
| RB | Dante Washington, Jr., Carthage | Jason Meyers, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| WR | Ricky Lannetti, Sr., Lycoming | Dusty Kain, So., Simpson |
| WR | Randell Knapp, Sr., Mount Union | Justin Salton, Sr., Franklin and Marshall |
| TE | Brian Whisler, Sr., Coast Guard | Seth Schussler, So., St. Norbert |
| OT | Chris Radomski, Sr., Muhlenberg | Matt Mendola, Sr., Lycoming |
| OG | Alex Bell, Jr., Hobart | Jonathan Sullivan, Sr., Bridgewater State |
| C | Matthew Atkins, Sr., Thomas More | Josh Towner, Sr., UW-Stout |
| OG | Lamont Moore, Jr., Shenandoah | Brent Miller, Sr., Mount Union |
| OT | Jason Holloway, Sr., Wilkes | Morgan Smith, Sr., Willamette |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Brad Keem, Sr., St. John Fisher | David Bleitner, Jr., Lake Forest |
| DT | Thomas DeMoss, Sr., Widener | Scott Paterson, Sr., New Jersey |
| DT | Ryan Weinandt, Sr., St. John's | Wil Goff, Sr., Redlands |
| DE | Michael Holbok, Jr. Buffalo State | Tiko Williams, Sr., Randolph-Macon |
| LB | Anthony Frate, Sr., Mount Union | Dominic Tomeo, Sr., Rowan |
| LB | Ray Meyer, Sr., Montclair State | Mike Bryant, So., Occidental |
| LB | Cam McCambridge, Sr., St. John's | Gary Nelson, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) |
| CB | Mike Miller, Sr., Mount Union | John Paniekiewsky, Sr., Moravian |
| S | Matt Campbell, Jr., Johns Hopkins | Mike Defilippi, Sr., RPI |
| S | John Ortega, Sr., Centre | Rocky Myers, Jr., Wesley |
| CB | Seth Koph, Sr., Knox | Nick Hajjar, Sr., Wooster |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Andy Beals, Sr., Millikin | Cliff Eisenhut, Sr., Union |
| P | Cory Ohnesorge, So., Occidental | Nick Schlieman, So., Augsburg |
| RET | Mark Tilki, Sr., Tufts | Taylor Ramos, So., Delaware Valley |
